Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re: Love the Prisoner. (Score 1) 49

It doesn't have a message, which is key to what makes it a work of profound brilliance. A pattern repeated in many fields is "to become good, you need to learn to follow the rules. To become great, you now need to learn to break them". "Art should have a message" is one of these rules. It limits the art to the scope of the message. This is far better than just making a big mess or a meaningless depiction of things, but the very best, when they're on form, can create meaning which goes far beyond the scope of any given message.

Comment Re:The last one was pretty lame... (Score 2) 49

The original was, of course, original, being made by people with ideas about the world they wanted to make art about, so it's simply expected for it to be far better than any remake. In general, I find "is it a remake? If yes, ignore it" to be an almost perfectly reliable heuristic. Anyone worth watching the art of will have better ideas than "remake this show which already exists and did a perfectly good job of doing its thing the first time".

Comment Re:one thing i've learned (Score 2) 86

This is certainly a trend which has continued to be true about the Western capitalist world over the course of centuries. However, it seems unlikely that long-term growth like this can go on forever, since infinite growth on a finite Earth seems unlikely to work, and right now, with global warming and other such problems starting to really bite, unexploited natural resources running out, and fascism popping up all over the world, it would be unsurprising if this turns out to be the point where it's stopping. Very hard to tell, of course.

Comment Re:Could have been worse (Score 1) 135

There's not much in the way of consensus about when Doctor Who is being successful or unsuccessful, or indeed what kinds of decisions are risky, so it's impossible to answer that. But the only time I can think of when a risk risk has gone badly wrong in my eyes was the characterisation of Colin Baker's Doctor. The biggest blunder of recent years IMO was hiring Chris Chibnall as a showrunner, and that was a safe decision (in BBC executive reasoning at least) since he'd already been showrunner for a successful show, the trouble being that he's no good at writing Doctor Who, probably because he's no good at writing science fiction and his instincts are to write cop shows. Take a risk on Mathieson or Harness and we could have got very different results.

Comment Legal requirement (Score 1) 103

It's certainly a legal requirement to disclose LLM usage in the UK, because if you just use a human-sounding pen name, you're making a false implied representation that you're selling a human-written book with intent to gain (profit) from it, which is fraud by false representation. The police may not want to prosecute anyone for doing anything which corporations do because they exist to serve the rich, but the law as written seems very clear.

It may also be a legal requirement to have permission from the authors of books still under copyright before you use a machine to produce a derivative of their work, but that's completely uncertain at the moment of course.

Comment Re: What we made ourselves .... (Score 1) 66

Without thousands upon thousands of human hand-coders creating the source material, LLMs can't do anything. One of the reasons LLM vendors want you to call them "AI" is so you forget that where you do manage to get something intelligent from them, it's coming from humans, who receive only, say, a DoS of their website for their contribution.

Comment Re:What we made ourselves .... (Score 1) 66

You're getting a million other coders to do the coding for you and then cutting them out of any credit and disregarding their licenses. There's nothing inherently wrong with assembling code with an LLM system, but if want to be decent about it, you should use a LLM which is only trained on code compatible with the license you will be asserting and present it as basically the work of all the people who wrote the training material. Certainly not turn it in as any sort of competition entry.

Comment Re:Bejesus - Beer and Circuses (Score 1) 53

I think the fantasy is one of autonomy. The world of cops and robbers is just the most popular place for it because American storytelling culture prioritises cops and robbers above all else. Half of all the films and TV shows which fans of American culture are always talking about seem to be about police and criminals, to the extent that "I don't want to spend my free time with a load of characters who are comfortable having a gun" is a significant part of the reason I mostly stick with British and Japanese stuff.

Comment Re:I keep hearing this but (Score 1) 191

There's already been several courts that have ruled that you can't look at individual inputs to an LLM's training data, and say "well, if 0.000001% of the training data was X, then the output of the LLM is X"

How does this work if you, say, take a C file from the Linux kernel which has been modified by hundreds of different people, include it in your proprietary program, and when asked for the source under the GPL, claim "no individual contributor's copyright actually covers a meaningful proportion of this file, so who am I violating the copyright of exactly"?

If this doesn't work because it;'s all GPL, then what if no individual person has provided a significant proportion of the training data, but 20% is GPLv2 only and 20% more is GPLv3 only?

Of course, when it comes to suing people in the courts, you need a plaintiff, but copyright also exists within criminal law in many places, and for criminal copyright infringement when pirates get arrested, maybe it's "what gives you the right to distribute copies of something that's only 0.0001% your own work?

Comment Re:Uhh... Cool? (Score 1) 191

First off, you can always just use a LLM with an open training dataset (OLMo, Pythia, etc) to prove that the data isn't in it, and have that handle the "clean" side of the equation.

Note that since free software projects with compatible licenses can share code freely, simply not finding that source amongst an enumeration of the sources is not going to be enough to prove none of the code was there. If all of the training data was explicitly provided with authorisation from the writers to feed it to a LLM and do whatever you want with the results, that would be better.

Secondly, you are under the mistaken impression that a LLM that has been exposed (which, BTW, does not mean "memorized", or even any rough understandings of the workings - ask the LLM (ideally an abliterated one to avoid refusals) to reproduce the original code verbatim, it'll almost certainly fail badly) automatically fails in such a suit. It does not. There is no such thing as "homeopathic copyright contamination". Copyvio requires substantial similarity.

The grey areas around copyright violation can change a lot depending on which legal system you're thinking of. Since you haven't specified which legal system you're thinking of, it's hard to know what you're claiming. But another formulation might be, say, "copyright violation is averted if the new input dominates the copied input", which would be game over for LLMs. All of this territory is a big fat "we don't know yet".

Comment Re:Begone. Give us the UNBIASED facts. (Score 1) 73

There's no way to decide which facts are important enough to include and which aren't required in an "unbiased" manner. Anything people write will inevitably be informed by their politics, and it's important to be conscious of this fact so that you know what you're actually doing.

Comment Re:Will AI ever make it better/more-secure? (Score 1) 26

If you use LLMs to find problems, but have humans fix them and generally keep your code 100% human-written, then LLMs will help find vulnerabilities but are unlikely to insert any. Plus you can still be confident of having the right to distribute your code since you haven't just made it a derivative of a ton of GLPv2-only code and also a ton of GPLv3-only code...

Still got to reconcile yourself to participating in the "make hot countries which have contributed little to the problem unliveable and then call the people who lived there 'illegal' when they try to escape" project and such, of course.

Slashdot Top Deals

"There is hopeful symbolism in the fact that flags do not wave in a vacuum." --Arthur C. Clarke

Working...