Comment Re:my solution to this problem (Score 1) 142
Hear, hear! but...
6) Too crude, how will AS people know why they have been blocked if they are blocked? Blocking whole AS might kill somebody or sombodies!
Maybe:
5.3) Block only offending addresses only from attack target with expiration time.
5.4) Contact AS operators by other means if they don't respond to email.
5.5) Require AS operators to have SIP phones, live chat and a contact person/s, or some why to know your email hasn't gone into a black hole.
5.6) If addresses proceed to attack other targets, redirect offending addresses to a "you have been blocked server" with remedies as "attacker" might be a hijacked PC. Not sure this option exists in bog standard routers but it exists in firewalls and some wi-fi hotspots. This would be routing on source address. Some sort of internet jail. Even when you arrest somebody they get food and basic necessities. You don't put them in solitary confiment without anything.
6) Off limits, nuclear option - in an interdependent world: how do you know you are not cutting off the branch you are sitting on, or an innocent is sitting on?
Retailiate, why? What is the point? What does it achieve?
That is a bit Old Testament: eye for an eye...
6) Too crude, how will AS people know why they have been blocked if they are blocked? Blocking whole AS might kill somebody or sombodies!
Maybe:
5.3) Block only offending addresses only from attack target with expiration time.
5.4) Contact AS operators by other means if they don't respond to email.
5.5) Require AS operators to have SIP phones, live chat and a contact person/s, or some why to know your email hasn't gone into a black hole.
5.6) If addresses proceed to attack other targets, redirect offending addresses to a "you have been blocked server" with remedies as "attacker" might be a hijacked PC. Not sure this option exists in bog standard routers but it exists in firewalls and some wi-fi hotspots. This would be routing on source address. Some sort of internet jail. Even when you arrest somebody they get food and basic necessities. You don't put them in solitary confiment without anything.
6) Off limits, nuclear option - in an interdependent world: how do you know you are not cutting off the branch you are sitting on, or an innocent is sitting on?
Retailiate, why? What is the point? What does it achieve?
That is a bit Old Testament: eye for an eye...