Comment Re:Information wants to be free (Score 2) 89
Torrenting the works is a bit different from just "reading" and "remembering" the information and incorporating it into new creative works. As part of the torrent process they also uploaded and shared the raw files with other torrenters. So even if you give them a pass on how they use the data after having "read" it, torrenting raises the issue of sourcing the raw, copyrighted, pirated files to others. It is the aspect of illegally uploading copyrighted materials through the torrent process that is seen as the new legal angle to act upon, not the reading and using aspect.