Comment Re:How is this victory for the complainants? (Score 1) 58
Their evidence proves Apple is currently carbon neutral on their watches now, and until at least 2029?
No. If the tree plantation does not survive to maturity, there is no carbon that has been "neutralized". Trees take time to grow and if the site is bulldozed and repurposed while the trees are still saplings, then nothing has been achieved.
Yes, and the court assumed without evidence that people buying "green" products expect a carbon neutrality scheme to be absolutely guaranteed for at least the next 25 years.
It wasn't an assumption. Carbon neutral programs that rely on tree plantations (and aren't just greenwashing scams) require guarantees that the trees will grow to maturity and wont be burnt down or bulldozed later on. If there are no or inadequate guarantees, then this might be just a greenwashing scam and Apple needs to get their shit together.