Comment Re:American's are not exceptional (Score 1) 619
I think I wasn't being clear in my original post, it happens.
I know there are people in other countries that are fantastically smart, definitely smarter than me. My issue isn't with smart immigrants. My issue is with the system that isn't bringing a ton of those smart people here, but instead bringing people with limited training, fake resumes (provided by the "body shop", I don't want to imply the immigrants are complicit), and low skills and then selling them as geniuses. I use to be told by people that since I was working with Indians, I must be on a very good team since they are so good with technology. They aren't... at least not any more than any other person. Entrepreneurs in India just figured out a way to game the system, coupled with entrepreneurs in the US.
And you're correct, American jobs aren't truly American, they should go to whoever has the proper merits to earn the position. Any job anywhere should.
However, I'm not competing against smart immigrants. I'm competing against falsified credentials/experience that come with a bargain of a significantly lower salary than I do. At that point, I lose, the client loses, and the immigrant loses as well... the only ones winning are the "body shops" for abusing the system and blatantly lying.