I get why Twitter users move to Bluesky, or Mastodon. They are similar products. But doesn't the fact that TikTok users specifically search for Chinese alternative prove the point that China is using these apps to gain soft power against western citizens ?
My main concern about TikTok has never been as much about data collection and privacy as it is that their algorithm, like on any other platform, can be imperceptibly skewed towards a nefarious goal over time. Most western apps skew towards advertiser's needs, and presumably towards surveillance state, which is already very bad and leads to an enshittification where products are built for the needs of shareholders and advertisers instead of their users'.
But what happens when your 'For you' that was formerly used to get you addicted to a platform slowly switches to content design to destabilize your country or push adversarial propaganda during a conflict ? This is a whole new level of enshittification.
I consider myself left of liberal and quite political, and I only used TikTok for a few weeks before I realized its algorithm was pushing me farther to the left and pushing more and more ideologies that aligned with China's authoritarian communist regime. I can't be the only one. This, plus the fact that this app is very addictive and serves no utilitarian purpose, led me to uninstall the app after just a few weeks. I am very wary of any TV where a foreign government holds the remote and has control over what people know, what they see, and what opinions they are exposed to as they see it.
They have no incentive in using it too heavily until their users are hooked, and it is worth blowing their cover. What about when the time comes ? The fact that hundreds of thousands of users are made to seek Chinese alternatives to TikTok tells me that the first part of this plan is in place.