Hm. I'm not a hardcore geek, but not a basic user either.
I moved to Windows 3.x because I needed the tcp/ip winsocket thing for internet access. Still was running games in dos4gw mode of course. The text typing app in windows was occasionally useful and better than the basic Dos edit thing, but then my old Amiga had a much better interface long before.
I went to Win 95 and that was a tremendous improvement despite all the bugs and the insane headaches getting everything configured. It was a pain but it -was- much better with a lot of things useful in there that I didn't have in Win 3.x. Of course, it broke a lot of the Dos games but hey, I could see that new games would use/need the stuff in Win 95.
98 came out and I pretty much ignored it. Didn't seem to have anything really useful and all games were made for 95/98 and word 95 worked fine thanks.
2k came out and I was given a laptop with it on it at work. Came to hate it when it hard crashed multiple times while I was working on some Word documents and lost everything without giving me a few seconds to copy/paste or even a grayed screen that allowed me to see what I had last typed and write out the outline on a paper or another machine(never had the issue on the last version of 95). Never used it outside of work, number of games didn't run on it anyway.
ME? hahaha
XP came out, and it -did- have a good number of actual improvements over 95(!). I made the switch, there were some bugs and issues but since it was offering me a lot of actual improvements for the basic stuff I was doing, I went through it. Sure was a LOT more stable compared =b
Same story as a lot of others, I read the reviews and decided to avoid vista. Unfortunately, when came time to buy a new laptop (old one went for a swim), couldn't find one with XP. Figured it couldn't be as bad as people said and got a new HP.
Vista Pros: I like the little internet icon that tells me if I'm connected to the network but not the internet.
It came with IE 7 which -is- better than 6 and that forced me to realize it (tabs are useful). That led me to try Firefox but doesn't work with some of the bank apps I use sorry :/
The default search is better than in xp
Vista cons: HELLLLLLLLOOOOO???????????????? What kind of an OS is it that runs out of resources and does NOT tell you when programs try to do stuff and fail???????????
You're sitting there with your usual 12 IE open, couple spreadsheets (openoffice, got tired of having to explain AGAIN to MS that yes, I was activating my legitimate paid-for copy of office xp on a new computer -again- because I changed it), Skype, Yahoo messenger, thunderbird and maybe WoW in the background.
And your coworker walks by and is surprised to see you and asks why you haven't replied to his Yahoo messages. At which point you try to send him a message and realize that you CANT! you get no error message, just... NOTHING! You double click again, and after a while understand that Vista just doesn't wanna do more than what it's currently doing and so is ignoring any requests to do so WITHOUT SAYING IT.
Means that if people send you messages, you don't get them and neither you nor them know about it.
Other cons: It's slow. Machine is a lot more powerful than the $300 HP/wallmart black friday laptop from a couple years back, and yet it's slow. Yes, I run a lot of stuff, but I did that on the older one (had 1.5gig of ram on it, didn't have a problem).
Did I mention I'm cheap and don't even have Aero since i have vista basic so it's not what's making it slow?
And what's up with the step backward on the task manager?? XP, app locks up, you ctrl/alt/del and you kill the app. Vista, app locks up, you do same... and sometimes, it doesn't work!!!! Or gets you to the useless menu about changing pw or switching user or buying pizza and when you click on "task manager"... it locks up again!!
DRM: Now I don't follow all the drm stuff, and I'm not trying to watch HD on anything so far, but I DO know that DRM stuff makes my hackles rise. And I do understand enough to know that MS is doing stuff that'll piss me off at some point because I've experienced it before. And from my understanding, all that DRM comes at a cost, which is to make my powerful machine slow. And that sucks.
So. I bought a mac. Thought about linux, but seemed a bit more complicated and I like my ipod... =b
Unfortunately, yahoo messenger on mac is retarded and doesn't have an option to save conversations (there's the online version, but 1) I have archives I need to transfer and 2) I need to access saves even when not online). And those same banking apps don't work on safari. So I still do the work stuff on the windows machine :/
World of Warcraft runs fantastic on macbook pro though, and the colors are awesome =b And I actually turn the laptop off sometimes when not using it since it's so fast to boot.
There -is- one windows xp con that drives me nuts, which is the utterly retarded way file names are displayed by default, with "hidden known extensions"!!!!!!!!!! Run into it ALL the time when dealing with basic users, who of course will be the ones to click on the nudepicofbushomg.jpg attachement not understanding that if the .jpg shows it means there is ANOTHER extension behind, such as maybe .exe. What the HECK is the benefit supposed to be????? I want to hurt puppies very badly everytime I run across a non-modified xp system :/
Sure, might have to reboot the machine once in a while if I went a bit overboard on the number of tabs and windows and programs I ran same time but otherwise, xp is great. Just wish I could have that little icon that tells me if I'm connected just to the network or the internet though...
Oh, and went and bought 4 laptops from Dell for the biz when they announced they were going to offer xp again.
CONCLUSION: Vista has problems that xp doesn't have. Those problems -may- or may not be solved in the future. Vista doesn't have ANY feature that I want that xp doesn't have (except for that little icon about network vs internet connection, did I mention I like that? =b)
For most users, I expect the same will be true so you are MUCH better off AVOIDING VISTA.