You're right, I don't like the show, but:
- Intelligent leader balks when unknown element with no trust rating tries to assert power. Relents when he decides the new element has a positive benefit/cost ratio.
--> Sounds good, I agree. In the case of Baltar, however, it doesn't compute. I guess I don't see Adama as the "Oh well, Thats Democracy, I'll just keep my mouth shut about the mumbling traitor that was elected" kind of guy.
- Desperate survivors of a holocaust who mostly never saw combt before their homes and families were wiped out of existence by a superior military force and who are cut off from all normal supply lines and logistical support resort to improvised guerilla warfare and traditional asymetrical tactics, as were probably defined in one of their field manuals anyways.
--> Despite NOT behaving anywhere near that for at least 1 season.
- Fighter Pilot from influential family with history of military and government service at the highest levels spontaneously goes Governor, then President of the most powerful country on the planet.
--> In one day? I went from lawn mower mechanic to computer scientist, but it took longer ;)
- Military unit's actions are strongly shaped by the personality and actions of their leader. Custer's men followed him to their deaths. The holocaust was perpetrated by men considered to be some of the finest, most elite soldiers alive. Other units of the german army were just regular people convinced they were protecting the interests of their homeland, and were not horrific war criminals.
Certainly it has happened before, and Cain's personality is definitely passed to the crew of the Pegasus. Conceded. Cain is _also_ the leader of the Galactica. The mindlessness doesn't seem to trickle down to Galactica though (i.e. The rest of the army doesn't fall in line). Meh, I'll give you this one :)