Comment Stereo interference 20kHz = audible diff tones (Score 1) 841
When two or more instruments play a loud chord, the interference of the inaudible overtones from each instrument produce a distinct "ring" of audible difference tones, audible only at live gigs and on well reproduced SACD recordings. I've seldom heard the same effect to the same degree from a CD. Don't be fooled, this is a real and reliable enough effect for us classical musicians to use it to tune chords. This "ring" should be reproducible in 24/192 when these HF overtones in the stereo or surround channels interfere, which a CD cannot reproduce since there's nothing > 20kHz.
Granted, as mentioned in TA, the amp and speakers need to not be so rubbish as to introduce distortion > 20kHz.
Whilst I can tell in a blind test between the CD and SACD mode of the same disc of a recent BIS recording of Carmina Burana, it's only during certain passages of music where I am listening out for the difference tone "ring". Most of the rest of the time, I can't tell, and 16/44 CDs sound great. I don't think the fact that I am a classically trained musician matters.
That said, I think it's important NOT to be under the illusion that, just because you can't hear anything over 20 kHz (actually, ~16 kHz for most people), that there are no audible consequences when there is more than one channel.
In fact, given that well mastered vinyl played on good cartridges can reproduce fequencies to 60 kHz and beyond, this live "ring" may help explain why some folks still prefer vinyl recordings of classical music to the CD.