Comment Nice offer. Here's a counter-proposal (Score 1) 243
Here's a compromise for AT&T: serve everyone as a utility or common carrier, but offer an optional alternative as an Online Service Provider, like AOL or Compuserve back in the day. Customers can choose which they prefer, with a price drop for the latter due to advertising and corporate subsidy.
If they truly believe that this sort of metering and customer-side QOS control is what their customer base wants, let them have it as an optional service and see just how many people sign up.