My wife was usnchooled (Score 1)

My wife was unschooled.

She got a BA in Philosophy with a 3.97 GPA (she got a C in public health... I still can't figure that one out..), along with a ton of awards. She is currently working on a PHD in Philosophy at a public ivy university on a full scholarship.

Her two siblings were also unschooled, and also graduated with honors, though not nearly as high as she did.

What it comes down to, though, is the people who are going to home or unschool are a self selected lot who are probably going to do a better job than a random idiot off the street, so YMMV.