Comment Re:Is coercion really the answer? (Score 1) 589
There are MRI machines made using a 3 tonne permanent magnet - which is "low field" and OK-ish for wrists and ankles.
There are MRI machines made using a 3 tonne permanent magnet - which is "low field" and OK-ish for wrists and ankles.
This isn't a problem about energy use, it's an issue about stability: a persistent current in an s/c magnet is incredibly stable, so you get a nice sharp MRI image.
There is one company making MgB2 MRI machines, and they run them at about 10K so far as I remember, using direct conduction instead of imersing them in a cryogenic liquid. You want to run the machine as cold as you can because then the current-carrying capacity of the s/c goes up.
This guy is living in a fantasy world. Helium use as a lifting gas in *all forms* is only 7% of helium use. Of that, party balloons are just a fraction. MRIs, on the other hand, use up 28% of helium consumption. And how could they possibly use so much? Because they do essentially nothing to recover it as it boils off.
Perhaps they should clean up their glass house before they start throwing stones?
Also, it's not like helium will become unavailable as we use up current stocks. It'll just increase in price by 1-2 orders of magnitude as we have to switch to getting it from chilling it out of the atmosphere in tiny quantities, the same way we recover other nobel gasses (but requiring more concentration). Now, of course that sucks, but it means that people who run MRI machines and do other such tasks will be forced to clean up their acts concerning helium recovery instead of simply casting blame on others.
In Japan, Helium has been more expensive for a while. So the major MRI manufacturers already produce recondensing He MRI machines for that market. There is still some leakage of course.
Exactly! Use liquid hydrogen to cool the large magnets inside MRI scanners.
Liquid hydrogen boils at 20.28 K. MgB2 superconducts at 39 K. (So neon would also work, but it has problems similar to helium.)
While this is good news for the one company in the world making MgB2 MRI machines (in Italy)... [High Temperature superconductrors don't do persistent magnets, so they can't be used], there is a much more important problem.
It is truly unique, and while material substitution can be expected for some applications (cf. MRI above), there are some where it is not just technology, but p*hysics*, which is telling us that there are no substitutes. IR detectors for astronomy have to be cooled as cool as you can get: and while you could use direct conduction and a fridge, with a liquid Hydrogen shield, that makes the vibation problem harder.
Having said that, it is perhaps just a matter of price. In principle we can extract Helium from granite: it would just be very, very, very expensive. In a couple of hundred years it might be cheaper to make it from seawater Lithium using a handy fusion reactor (with MgB2 magnets, of course), or from Jupiter's atmosphere...
"Take that, you hostile sons-of-bitches!" -- James Coburn, in the finale of _The_President's_Analyst_