Comment Composition of Plume Variable (Score 1) 284
Let's get objective for a moment. The stuff that comes out of a volcano is immensely variable in composition -- many of the thousands of rock types on our plant started as lava -- some rather benign and others highly toxic and corrosive -- and with differing melting temperatures and pH. Some volcanic plumes are loaded with droplets of sulfuric acid and other nasties -- this particular volcano apparently has significant fluorine -- one of the nastiest elements that exist.
There have been plane crashes involving aircraft that frequent places like Hawaii, caused, they say, by corrosion from the salty particles in the air from sea spray.
One size can't fit all when it comes to potential harm to an aircraft from a cloud from an eruption. And as in the Hawaii example, it can be a cumulative condition over time as well as the widely-publicized catastrophic failures during flight. I'm all for prudence when air safety is concerned.
Perhaps those who depend upon "just-in-time" everything need a model with room for delays, and alternative supply lines.