Your job, everyone's job, is to make your boss look good.
Your boss wants to use up his entire budget, and deliver a working solution as promised. There doesn't have to be any connection between those two. I think that the gpp was proposing that you help chose a proprietary system which would burn up the budget, and that you use you spare time to set up a F/OSS system which would work.
When the proprietary system fails, put the free one on to cover the gap. Now that it's working, it's pretty hard to argue that it can't do the job. Your boss has used the money, he's gotten the kickbacks from the salesmen, he's delivered a solution, you've made him look good. As long as he gets to take credit for everything, you'll be sticking around.
Those are your knowledgeable users, who read and understood your message.
A simulation can tell you things you didn't realize you knew, but it can't tell you things you actually didn't know.
All argument by analogy leads you astray as soon as the anaolgy breaks down.
When you run the game of Life, you learn about the behavior of the cells on the game board under the rules you put into the simulation. You learn all the things which are implicit in the rules, but not obvious to you. Since you make up all the rules, there is no underlying reality with hidden rules which can make reality differ from your simulation.
Running a simulation can let you see that reality differs from the results of your model. From that you can infer that there are rules in reality that didn't make it into your model.
SLASHDOT CAMP 2007 - BOOK NOW!!!
Hey Slashboteers! Are you finishing university? *STILL* unemployed after the dot com layoffs? Desperately trying to get a LAMP cluster to perform better than an IBM Model 55 running Vista? Well, have we got the answer for you! Chief Executive Officer Rob Malda and SS Officer Michael Sims invite you to join them at the Black River Public School in Holland, Michigan from the 1st November 2007 for the "/. 10th Anniversary Slashbot Camp." Three full days of pony rides, Linux coding and male bonding. Special Appearances by NAMBLA Grand Wizard Katz with his partner Wai Tu Yung.
Activities include:
Tickets are US$125 each, and the event lasts for three days. For more information, or to book a place, contact CmdrTaco
Terms & Conditions:
Spaces are limited to how many people we can lock in a basement. Camp is open to males aged between 12 and 19. No soap is allowed on the premises. CmdrTaco's Jubei cabinet is not to be used as a simulated coffin for sex games without his involvement. KDawson's 5w Creative speakers must not be turned up to eleven.
Funding
Why Libre?
Wasted Effort
How can it be good if it's free?
Exporting jobs
Today, we usually use the term ``professional'' to mean ``mercenary'', as in ``someone who does it for money''. ``Amateur'' is often used to mean: ``bad'', though its original meaning of: ``someone who does it for love'' is a better fit for most open-source developers.
I don't think that in general we should assign right to IP. But there are specific cases in which it is best to do so, and when we do assign such rights, it must be possible for corporations to own them.
The decision doesn't have to be logical; it was unanimous.