Comment Re:Even More Simple (Score 1) 736
If there is a worst case breach, and you have 0 psi behind the capsule, and 15 psi in front, then you will get rapid deceleration of the capsule. However, the deceleration may not be as catastrophic as some commentators have suggested.
Some youtubers have even demonstrated dramatic acceleration with ping pong balls or bearing balls in a tube. This is a bad analogy, because they do not take into account the mass of the capsule (which scales by r^3) in relation to the force on it (which scales by r^2). Applying realistic mass and areas to the capsule, the acceleration in such a worst case breach comes out to something like 1.4 g - which is the deceleration I get if I mash the brake pedal in my car. If you're sitting down and strapped in, then it would be uncomfortable but relatively harmless. Even if not strapped in, just smacking into a seat or table would cause limited harm. Of course, if you're standing up and walking down the aisle, then you will be in big trouble.
Even this calculation doesn't take into account the fact that the capsule is not intended to seal like a piston against the sides of the tube, thus any such pressure difference is unlikely to be maintained. Additionally, most leaks are likely to be slow, and this type of guillotine break can be engineered out by using designs and materials which tend to undergo hairline cracking before catastrophic failure.
Some youtubers have even demonstrated dramatic acceleration with ping pong balls or bearing balls in a tube. This is a bad analogy, because they do not take into account the mass of the capsule (which scales by r^3) in relation to the force on it (which scales by r^2). Applying realistic mass and areas to the capsule, the acceleration in such a worst case breach comes out to something like 1.4 g - which is the deceleration I get if I mash the brake pedal in my car. If you're sitting down and strapped in, then it would be uncomfortable but relatively harmless. Even if not strapped in, just smacking into a seat or table would cause limited harm. Of course, if you're standing up and walking down the aisle, then you will be in big trouble.
Even this calculation doesn't take into account the fact that the capsule is not intended to seal like a piston against the sides of the tube, thus any such pressure difference is unlikely to be maintained. Additionally, most leaks are likely to be slow, and this type of guillotine break can be engineered out by using designs and materials which tend to undergo hairline cracking before catastrophic failure.