Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Theory or fact? (Score 1) 672

I think I have the definitions of fact and theory well in hand:

From Merriam Webster:

theory noun \th--r, thir-\
plural theories
Definition of THEORY
1: the analysis of a set of facts in their relation to one another
2: abstract thought : speculation
3: the general or abstract principles of a body of fact, a science, or an art
4a : a belief, policy, or procedure proposed or followed as the basis of action
b : an ideal or hypothetical set of facts, principles, or circumstances —often used in the phrase in theory
5: a plausible or scientifically acceptable general principle or body of principles offered to explain phenomena
6a : a hypothesis assumed for the sake of argument or investigation
b : an unproved assumption : conjecture
c : a body of theorems presenting a concise systematic view of a subject
  See theory defined for English-language learners
See theory defined for kids
Examples of THEORY

a widely accepted scientific theory
Her method is based on the theory that all children want to learn.
There are a number of different theories about the cause of the disease.
She proposed a theory of her own.
Investigators rejected the theory that the death was accidental.
There is no evidence to support such a theory.
He is a specialist in film theory and criticism.
The immune surveillance theory of cancer holds that in a way we all do have cancer, that a healthy immune system fights off rogue cells as they appear. —Sallie Tisdale, Harper's, June 2007
[+]more

fact noun \fakt\
Definition of FACT

1: a thing done: as
a obsolete : feat
b : crime
c archaic : action
2 archaic : performance, doing
3: the quality of being actual : actuality
4a : something that has actual existence
b : an actual occurrence
5
: a piece of information presented as having objective reality
— in fact
: in truth
  See fact defined for English-language learners
See fact defined for kids
Examples of FACT

Rapid electronic communication is now a fact.
The book is filled with interesting facts and figures.
He did it, and that's a fact.

Comment Theory or fact? (Score -1, Troll) 672

These stories always amuse me.

The folks that are religious about the "truth" of the big bang, evolution, climate change or any other theory try to defend presenting the THEORY as scientific fact in the name of good science. Whether you believe in it or not, it is just plain silly to present it as fact. Theory and fact are two very different things.

It is dishonest to present these theories as fact, no matter how convinced you are of their truthfulness, they remain theories. There are plenty of goons on both sides of the argument, but you have to admit that there are just as many people who are closed minded and simply unwilling to accept reality who are in favor of these theories as are against them.

Comment Re:Do non-Iranians have a voice? (Score 1) 301

Of course I don't care for their attitude toward women, domestic violence etc. My point is that no one nominated the US as the global cop and they don't appreciate our trying to fill that role. The question here is not whether a nation is behaving in a way that we are comfortable with - the question is whether one nation has a right to waltz in and reshape another nation. It is a very tricky thing to translate individual morality to the national level. You really do NOT want the national government making moral pronouncements. Trust me - it is a really bad idea. History is full of example where the national governments made horrible messes (with the best intentions).

If we really care about human rights, and I mean really care then why are we not more directly involved with the genocide in the various African countries? The answer is that we don't care about human rights - it is a shill that politicians use to excuse their abuse of power.

The founders of the US knew that this would happen, they feared it. Washington made it very clear in his final speech in office - he warned the people to not get involved in the old world national issues.

Comment Re:Immenant Disaster... (Score 1) 61

I did read part of the FM :) My comment wasn't intended to suggest that any robot of non-humanoid shape would meet the requirements, just that humanoid shape isn't a requirement - only the illustration.

You are correct - the requirements are stiff. Many of the challenges lend themselves better to a multi-legged chassis with manipulators that can handle tools. The human form is tricky for a number of reasons, odd center of gravity, etc. that are more suited to biological form than a machine. This looks like a great challenge.

Comment Re:Do non-Iranians have a voice? (Score 1) 301

In this case Iran isn't trying to control the internet, they are choosing to unplug themselves (or parts of their populate). I say that is a problem for Iran, not the rest of the world. I don't want anyone telling me what to do with my "intertubes" and I don't want to tell other countries what to do with their intertubes. Now, if an elected official in the US tried a stunt like that I would be all over that like a hobo on a ham sandwich - but the US is MY country.

I don't like the idea of fetters of any kind - if folks want to hurt themselves they should be able to as long as it doesnt involve me. This goes back to the 2 fundamental points in common law:

1. Do everything you agree to do.
2. Do not encroach on others or their property.

Comment Do non-Iranians have a voice? (Score 4, Insightful) 301

I think it is silly for any government to do something like sensor "the internet" - but is what Iran does in their country my business?

I find it amusing that we (the US in my case) often feel we have a right to tell other countries how to govern themselves, how to run their industry, how to run their elections, etc. Where does any country get off thinking it can tell another country what to do? I am not defending the criminal heads of state - just saying that we wouldn't take kindly to another country deciding how things should work in the US, deciding who they would allow to serve in elected office etc.

When will people realize that we need to leave people alone. If the Iranians want a different government then it is up to them to make one. Every single time the US tries to force other countries to behave it results in piles of corpses and enormous debt and a giant dose of hate directed at the US by BOTH sides of the conflict in the foreign country.

Comment I telecommute 3/5 days each week (Score 2) 275

I have telecommuted 3/5 days each week for almost 6 years at the same company, here are a few observations:

- be in the office the same days each week so that people know where/when to find your face
- make your work visible, send status reports in even if they are not asked for
- speak up on a call, if you have nothing to contribute then make jokes, use humor but make sure your voice is heard
- when you are in the office, work hard
- make sure folks see you online in instant messenger when your are at home

Comment Let History be your guide to free markets (Score 2, Funny) 530

As western civilization has grown through the industrial revolution we have found that as technology replaces skill sets and workers it typically frees them up for more profitable work. A specific set of jobs is replaced, but those workers are then put to work on something that is ultimately more productive. In a command economy this would be a problem, in a capitalist economy those workers will be employed in the next role until that one is replaced as well.

Science

Submission + - Five reasons the U.S. tech lead is in danger (computerworld.com) 3

dcblogs writes: The U.S. has yet to put in place a plan for building exascale systems, as Europe, China, Japan race ahead. The Europeans are prepared to commit up to 3.5 billion Euros to their effort and believe the race is wide open. "The U.S., Europe, China and Japan all have the potential to realize the first exascale system," concluded the European Exascale Software Initiative, the group that's leading Europe's effort, in a report last month. But in the U.S.: "The bottom line is that the US appears stalled and the EU, China, and Japan are gearing up for the next generation,” said Jack Dongarra, a professor of computer science at University of Tennessee, and one of the organizers of the Top 500. In 2008, China had 15 systems on the Top 500 list; it now has 74.

Comment Re:tough to be unbiased (Score 1) 585

I agree that science should NOT be done that way, however as a matter of fact some researchers DO start with a conclusion. Read your history books, there are plenty of ideas that were the result of "science", were widely accepted by the culture only to be disproved later. Some of the best examples come from the 20th century - look up eugenics for a start.

Anyone who has worked with statistics knows that nearly every set of numbers that represent a non-trivial set of data MUST rely on their experience and training to interpret the data. Numbers are only useful when interpreted with an understanding of causal relationships and background.

You are being naive if you think that scientists are infallible, superhuman or don't have their own predispositions. The important thing is for them to recognize their own bias and to balance their work against it.

These "scientists" have a clear bias and are making every effort to hide that bias - this draws their research into question.

Comment Re:tough to be unbiased (Score 0) 585

I think you have confused documented historical fact with theory.

The history of the holocaust is a document historical fact with eye witnesses.

The "theory" of evolution is exactly that - a theory, not a fact. Natural selection lends itself a little more closely to being labeled fact, evolution as the origin of the species has far too many problems to be elevated beyond theory.

The moon shot is a documented historical fact, again with eye witnesses.

The question of anthropogenic global climate change is not a question of whether people are rational, rather it is a question of whether we have a theory or a set of facts. The facts may suggest their theory, however the facts fail to prove the theory.

Slashdot Top Deals

The hardest part of climbing the ladder of success is getting through the crowd at the bottom.

Working...