Comment Devil's Advocate (Score 1) 228
However, part of me thinks this would be great because Tarantino's strength is making solid movies with interesting and compelling plots while at the same time paying homage to old movie styles and in the process coming up with a great example of the same.
For example Kill Bill is a really great movie in the style of old kung fu flicks. Death Proof has maybe the best car chase scene ever filmed. Jackie Brown is a great homage to blaxploitation films.
Everyone agrees Star Trek II: Wrath of Kahn is the best entry in the series. They tried to remake it twice (Nemesis and STID), with the second time even using a rebooted Kahn, and they both missed the mark. I don't think WoK needs to be attempted again but if Tarantino could pull off a new movie with an original plot that brought back the elements we loved about the old movies, it could be pretty interesting.
The one thing I hope though is this doesn't count as one of his ten films. He's said his thought process is that after he's done ten films he's retiring. Pretty much just for the fuck of it. He counts the two Kill Bill movies as one entry, so The Hateful Eight is his eighth film (it's even in the title). That means he has two more to go. I would hope his entry in a sci-fi anthology movie series wouldn't count against the ten. He's said he wouldn't completely rule out another film outside the ten if he felt like it so maybe he wouldn't count this one. Who knows.