Up to a point. A major part of the issue here is the apparent double standard. Professors and students at universities have been disciplined for far less. One has things like Nicholas Christakis at Yale who was forced by the administration to resign for merely suggesting that the university shouldn't be in the business of policing Halloween costumes for cultural appropriation. We've had students forced to attend diversity training for using things that might be racial slurs even when they were clearly not intended as such. Etc. Etc. So then, when students are using a slogan where a large fraction of the people using that slogan are using it to mean literal genocide, for that case to not be treated the same way is a clear double standard. It is that sort of deep inconsistency that is a major part of the issue. Heck, even if they had tried to say that the earlier statements were not genocide, and had said that calls for genocide would be unacceptable, that would at least be halfway to being reasonable here. I don't think that Magill should have resigned over this, but there's some pretty relevant bits.