Comment Re:So Basically What You're Asking Is (Score 1) 357
Let's face it, work visas are handed out like bouncers controlling admission to a club. You are asking these questions that sound like they treat people with respect and offer them opportunity but what I hear is basically: Are you going to be a net positive for the United States? And how do we accurately measure the Nikola Teslas and Yao Mings from the Dr. Nasser al-Aulaqis (Fullbright Scholar and father of Anwar al-Awlaki).
You know what? It's a dirty business and I don't want any part of it. In my own humble opinion, it's unethical. Your questions sound like "Can we implement a brain drain on the rest of the world with little or no risk?" I think it should be all law-abiding individuals or none and, despite 9/11 and the Mariel Boatlift that consisted of criminals and mental patients, I personally lean toward letting everyone in unless they are known to have committed or been convicted of crimes in their country of origin that are 1) credible sentences and 2) also misdemeanors or higher in the United States.
+5 Insightful.
In a way, I see a parallel between how open a country should be with how open software should be. The fundamental philosophy behind the two things is the same, in my humble opinion. Just like software, a country, especially the USA, will NOT go bankrupt or even lose its income earning potential if it recognizes that intellect and intellectual property should be nurtured and left free, not be caged and locked away. I may sound over the top while making this comment, but there are very few countries that can pull this off, and the USA is probably one of the very few. Look at any country that has a static population that doesn't travel much or even one that is from the old world, and you will see all the negative things amplify over time - corruption, narrow mindedness, bureaucracy, laziness, to name a few.
If a society does not embrace change or becomes too insular, it will die or will become slow and sluggish to a point of no return. This has happened to societies time and again - look at China and India or even many of the European countries that are slowly sliding down the slope such as Greece. They were once great nations only because they actively traveled and traded and moved about freely - over time, when they stopped doing so, their societies rotted to the point where other puny nations and kingdoms walked all over them. Even after countless wars etc, the seeds they left in the form of systemic corruption, bureaucracy, etc. sustain themselves for thousands of years.
It is sad to see that so many countries still fail to see the danger of insulating themselves from immigrants or from other cultures. At the end of the day, the intelligent, the dynamic, the risk takers, the people who keep a society alive, will get what they want one way or the other. They are also the ones who have the gumption to leave behind everything they know and that is comfortable into an unknown culture. I've often wondered why countries are brain dead enough to not see this obvious fact.