Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:True story .... (Score 1) 677

Obvious question: what is 95% confidence supposed to mean? How is it different from say 94%?

As long as the student cannot come up with something like "there is a chance of 5 in 100 that the result was caused by the sampling process" he has no idea what he is talking about.

Speaking of critical thinking, the student should also understand that one in twenty results with 95% confidence will be wrong.

Comment Re:Banking doesn't usually require anonymity (Score 1) 114

Just some thouhgts: The paper ballot can be understood and verified by every voter. The technique used may be simple, but the protocol is quite sophisticated. To verify the system you propose, you would still need to repeat all calculations. Also, how do you verify that the random numbers are really random? Your argument for stochastic verification suffers from a lack of randomness. The 0.1% percent that actually check will be far from random. Electronic voting is supposed to make the voting process easier. Manual verification of hashes of several hundred bits is not my idea of simplicity.

Comment Re:Banking doesn't usually require anonymity (Score 1) 114

Even if this works in theory, there may be flaws in the implementation. And even if implemented correctly, there may be issues with key management.

But most importantly, for 99,9% of the voters, it is impossible to understand the system, let alone verify the actual vote. Therefore, it is just a matter of time (or money) before some manipulation by insiders takes place.

Comment Re:Banking doesn't usually require anonymity (Score 1) 114

The real problem with electronic voting vs banking comparison is that banking has a completetly different aim: earning money.

Electronic banking is not secure. Period. E.g. in 2008, in the U.K. online banking fraud caused losses in the order of 50 Million Pounds. However, the banks still make a profit. ("It's just the cost of doing business...")

This kind of thinking is a bit problematic with voting.

Slashdot Top Deals

The hardest part of climbing the ladder of success is getting through the crowd at the bottom.

Working...