Comment stress-related illness (Score 1) 157
the effects of stress in exacerbating and causing physical ailments is one that is well understood. many people naively believe that genes are the sole exclusive means by which illness may occur, despite there being innumerable counter-examples clearly demonstrating that this is false. that does not prevent people from *believing* that genetics is the sole exclusive cause of one particular illness or another, and *for such people*, that belief, when they are presented with such "quotes truth quotes", is quite likely to result in their death, due, ironically, to stress *triggering* the very illness that is merely latent rather than active within their genes.
here on slashdot we have people who, by and large, are capable of logical and rational thought. when presented with scientific issues, they apply rational bullshit filters on the topic of for example genetics. many of the opinions marked "insightful" on this article are a clear demonstration of that. however the general population has little understanding of genetics, and many many people simply do not think "rationally".
on the whole then, if it became a *legal requirement* to *force* people to listen to a doctor telling them words which, when that person heard them, were translated in their own minds due to their lack of knowledge and self-belief, that "they were basically dead already because of their genes", i would consider such people who pushed such laws through as being severely mentally ill as well as their actions being morally reprehensible.
answer: no. it is highly irresponsible to force absolutely everyone to listen to something that they are not fully equipped to comprehend.