Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Duh? (Score 1) 245

Selfishness includes the desire for food and shelter, is it an evolutionary benefit to demand neither? This whole argument is absurd.

Is it absurd? Would you demand neither food nor shelter if doing so allowed your progeny both(not unreasonable you may be asked to sacrifice both for your kids)? Tricky isn't it? Never argue with a drunk guy... He won't ever realise you won or lost... :P

Comment Re: Duh? (Score 1) 245

Honestly dude, I'm not sober enough for this. But it does sound reasonable.... What if we could survive despite our destruction of nature? Why should we be custodians? It seems arbitrary. Why would intelligence make us better custodians? Surely obedience to the goal is more important? I have, I suppose, my own internal answers, but I think it is important to go on asking. When marginally sober at least...

(Thank goodness for spell checkers...) Ok. I quit for bed now,. It is 11 at night here.

Comment Re:I would love to wait (Score 1) 249

Advertising revenue? In South Africa? BBC Entertainment consists of advertising for (guess what?) BBC Entertainment. As with Discovery and Nat Geo, so no, no advertising lost. Their costs are covered by my US$ 80 subscription. Perhaps I am not the group he is referring to, but that does not imply that I (or my colleagues) abruptly cease to exist.... Admittedly discovery advertises a process control company(Nelson Concentrators, during Gold Rush Alaska) with which I admittedly have association with, but then I'm hardly likely to buy my own product am I? A surprisingly large number of people here subscribe to DSTV... And we still don't get why you would want to advertise a channel you're already watching....

Comment Re: Duh? (Score 2) 245

Interesting...

Is it selfishness as a species or as a group of individuals that leads to an ecosystem collapse? As a species, doesn't selfishness mean survival at any cost? Even the extreme cost of preserving the ecosystem? Perhaps the error is that we are selfish on the wrong level - as individuals rather than as a species. I am admittedly drunk, but it sounds like a rather profound question, so, what the heck, I'm asking.

Comment Re: Duh? (Score 1) 245

Well done AC, you have made me laugh! Let us then do this thing, not because he is necessarily wrong but for the nobility of our cause!

To be fair to him, I suspect he is implying 'general selfishness' (i.e. selfishness as a species) is 'better' (whatever that means) than individual selfishness. I might be wrong, but I am certainly 7 440ml beers down, so wrong is relative........

Comment Re:Duh? (Score -1, Flamebait) 245

I am not American. While I am profoundly grateful for that fact, I have to admit that my understanding of your dream is a nightmare - in all honesty, that may well be because I misunderstand it, or perhaps I am just an over-privileged descendant of the great British Empire. It is understood that in order to succeed there must be some stepping on of others. We have just made it a bit less subtle about it in Africa.

Slashdot Top Deals

"I've seen it. It's rubbish." -- Marvin the Paranoid Android

Working...