I hate software controlled cars, which is funny because I drive a Tesla Model 3, probably one of the most software controlled cars in existence.
The reason I hate them is the second guessing of the driver. Some engineer ( or his manager ) decided it doesn't make sense to allow me to depress both the brake and accelerator at the same time. Why would you want to? Well, one reason I hit often is because I'm trying to dry the brakes off. But, the car won't let me, instead putting up a modal error message ( without even an override option ). There are similar nannies for trying to get out of the car when it isn't in park, or trying to change between forward and reverse when the car is rolling more than a couple miles per hour.
It's not just an electric car thing, though. It's a "modern car" thing.
Automatics will ignore you if you try to command such a low gear that you'll over-rev the engine ( to be fair, those types of nannies predate software controlled vehicles by many decades ).
And that brings me to the subject people are discussing... Manuals and the feeling of control and connectedness... One of the advantages of a manual is that it will do what you command, when you command it, no matter how crazy. It you decide to see what will happen if you put the car in reverse at 40 mph... it will let you find out! ( and you'll feel like a fool when the shop gives you the repair estimate ).
If you're someone who predominantly thinks of automobiles as a way to get from a to b, and especially if you have an automatic ( ignoring dual clutch ) then you probably like the protection that the nannies provide.
But if you're commenting here about how modern ( non dual clutch ) transmissions are pretty much as good as a manual... Well, you just don't get it, and nothing I say will likely convince you. If you don't know how to toe-and-heel, double clutch, etc, well then... sigh.... please just accept that you're missing a whole aspect of driving that is hard to explain and you'll just probably never understand. But please don't be arrogant enough to think you understand the situation enough to comment intelligently.
I do have to say that electric cars have saved me from a choice I thought I might have to make on my next car... Full manual vs dual clutch. Because you really can't argue with a high performance dual clutch system in a modern sports car for going fast... And yet, I love having a clutch. There are all kinds of subtleties in learning to use a clutch which again, give you a connectedness and control over the car that nothing else can touch, including dual clutch systems... ( I cringe that modern cars have rev matching systems! ).
The original article that we're all commenting on is a pathetic attempt at journalism by someone who knows very little about the subject they're trying to write about. They missed the key points by a mile.
Some of the reader comments have been pretty good, though...