Comment Re: This might be a problem for short sellers (Score 1) 316
The NHTSA ratings are not subjective, they are based on scientific experiments performed on the vehicle measuring structural integrity of the vehicle and force of impact on the test dummies which is a function of force absorption achieved by the vehicle's structure and its active and passive safety features. There were five other vehicles made by four manufacturers (Ford, Honda, Subaru and Toyota - no Volvo, by the way) that also received five star ratings in all categories. NHTSA provides more detailed data, but they digest the data into coarse "star" ratings for easier public consumption. However, the detailed data showed the Tesla Model 3 achieving the lowest probability of injury of any car they ever tested.
Those are the facts. All the other comments about subjective ratings, poorly designed and distracting controls, driver attentiveness, etc., are just spin - mostly by people who have never driven a Tesla Model 3 or who own a Volvo and can't accept that even Volvos don't score as well in safety tests (hint: it's because of the unavoidably massive chunk of metal sitting under the hood).