Danish Court Rules Deep Linking Illegal 382
Jstein writes "In a court ruling today Friday, the court in Copenhagen, Denmark ruled in favor of the Danish Newspaper Publisher's Association against the online news aggregator Newsbooster. Thereby deep linking has been ruled illegal for the first time." Currently the story is
only in Danish (from Computerworld Denmark, Online).
Update: 07/05 23:15 GMT by T : ttyp writes "Here is a link to an
English language story about the Danish deep linking case."
breakin the law (Score:5, Interesting)
Deep linking implications (Score:5, Interesting)
There are technological ways around deep linking, of course. Checking the Referer header in an HTTP request is one option, and dynamically creating unique URIs on the pages you allow people to visit from is another.
It would be nice if technology was used to prevent this rather than court rulings, but hey, what can you do?
Anyway it's only been ruled in Denmark, so the effect on the Internet as a whole is negligible.
Re:Sighs (Score:3, Interesting)
On the other hand, I probably would never find out about that site because nobody would link to them.
Also, in order to enforce the ruling they're probably going to have to implement that referrer check on the server anyways, which somebody could easily fake the referrer if they really wanted to get around it.
Please note: (Score:2, Interesting)
No more search engines either (Score:4, Interesting)
This comes down to the fact that web advertising doesn't work. Unlike telly there's none of this having to watch adds to watch the program crap.
Really deeplinking to advertisers I spose is like being able to instantly fast foreward to the actionshots in a movie that some network's broadcasting.
When will these news sites learn that they're going to have to pr0n up their sites if they want to make money from them.
What exactly is a Deep Link? (Score:1, Interesting)
Unless they put on EVERY page that the users must start at a particular page, I can't imagine the concept of a deep link.
The company I currently work for (which has a really stupid marketing team) has on our web pages "No part of this website may be reproduced, or an external link established to this website, without the express written permission of an officer of *****." Of course, I don't have written permission of an officer, so I might get in trouble. :-P Guess this will have to go as an anonymous post (I want the karma!!).
Some of the stupid people have really enforced it, and a web search for my company reveals nothing. We're not on google. We're not on any major search engine that I can find, and it is quite funny. I told the people the problem with this, and they just don't get it. Thank goodness for anonymous posts.
I agree with the other posters -- people who don't understand the net whould not be allowed to publish on it or regulate it. That includes laywers and marketers.
Is not a Web page public? (Score:1, Interesting)
Could I really prohibit people from saying, "Gee, go look at Lenny's poster all about his pet cat Spot that is hanging on the library's bulletin board, lower left hand side, next to the notice about next week's book sale."
And is not the Internet an equally public place, accessible to all? This tastes so of the limiting of the freedom of expression to me. Oops, sorry, can't say more...I might be linking...
Re:Hmmm. (Score:3, Interesting)
Doh! I think I'm a dumbass! I was still thinking about the Deutsche Bahn case... I'll excuse my self for not reading the article though :-)
If that's really what the deal is, then frankly they shouldn't be so stupid. There are easy technical solutions to stop people deep-linking in the way you suggest, such as checking the "Referrer" header and redirecting to an index page or some other page that encloses the page in a frame, etc, if you've come from outside the site. I don't see the need for courts to be involved, when there's a perfectly good technical solution.
Summary available at Yahoo (Score:5, Interesting)
Googling in Denmark? (Score:1, Interesting)
Sites of the danish members of DDS:
*www.berlingske.dk
*www.bt.dk
www.bornhol
*www.borsen.dk
www.bergske.dk
www.
*www.information.dk
*www.eb.dk
ww
www.fynsamtsavis.dk
www.helsingordagb
www.herningfolkeblad.dk
www.venstrebladet
www.horsens-folkeblad.dk
www.jv.dk
*www.jp.
www.kal-folkeblad.dk
www.kj-avis.dk
*www.kri
www.licitationen.dk
www.folke
www.midtjyllandsavis.dk
www.nordjyske
www.nordschleswiger.dk
www.sj-nyheder.dk
*w
www.randersamtsavis.dk
www.skive
www.vejleonline.dk
www.weekend-avis
www.stiften.dk
www.bladkompagniet.dk
www.
www.lp.dk
www.jobdanmark.dk
www.flensborg-avis.de
www.ftonline
www.metropol-online.dk
www.ritzau.dk
www.se
www.sosialurin.fo
www.tipsbladet.dk
You should especially go for the major nationwide ones with real news sites. (marked *)