Compare ASTRA Pro vs. OpenBuildings Designer

ASTRA Pro features optional applications for structural analysis and design tailored to reinforced cement concrete (RCC) framed multi-story buildings, RCC tunnel linings supported by steel ribs, and RCC portals that take into account rock quality designation (RQD) and rock mass rating (RMR), as well as designs for RCC and prestressed concrete (PSC) jetties. The software provides comprehensive analysis and design information in a step-by-step format, along with a complete array of editable CAD drawings. However, in the demo version, users cannot modify the default input data, and the available drawings are restricted to view-only access. Each design module is accompanied by complete reports and drawings, forming a cohesive set. Additionally, detailed estimations for bill of quantities (BoQ), item rates, and costs are available for various types of bridges, including girder bridges, box-type bridges/culverts, and composite bridges. ASTRA Pro serves as a specialized tool for engineering design, facilitating the creation of RCC 'T' girder bridges, composite bridges featuring steel plate or box girders, and RCC deck slabs configured for both single and multi-span layouts, whether straight or curved, as well as PSC 'I' girder bridges, PSC box girder bridges, continuous PSC box girder structures, and steel truss bridges. This software not only enhances design accuracy but also streamlines the engineering workflow for a variety of complex structures.

OpenBuildings Designer, previously known as AECOsim Building Designer, is Bentley's comprehensive solution for multi-discipline building information modeling (BIM). It enables users to explore, innovate, and expedite the design and construction of buildings more efficiently than ever before. With the ability to design, analyze, document, and visualize structures of varying sizes and complexities, it enhances communication of design intent while overcoming obstacles between different building disciplines and teams located in different regions. The software empowers users to advance their building information modeling practices, leading to quicker project delivery and increased assurance in aspects such as design integrity, workflow efficiency, and overall productivity. By fostering collaboration among architects, mechanical, electrical, and structural engineers through a unified set of tools and processes, it streamlines project management. Furthermore, users can seamlessly integrate information from various formats and confidently tackle projects of all scales, ensuring that their design intentions are communicated clearly with customizable and dependable deliverables. This comprehensive approach ultimately transforms the building design process, making it more cohesive and effective.