Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
User Journal

Journal Abm0raz's Journal: Blackout opinion 14

The following is just an opinion and in no way meant to sway anyone involved as everyone is entitled to their opinion, no matter how diametrically opposed it may be from another.

***********************************************

What do you hope to accomplish by blacking out? Getting a few mod points? I get mod points roughly every other week. I thought that was a lot. I usually only use 3 or 4 of them and have yet to been M2'd for correction. I also read the journals every day (usually 4-5 times a day) as well as browse the Frontpage occasionally, a few replies and sometimes I check out the YRO, Science, and Ask Slashdot sections.

This blackout seems to be an attempt at one of several things:
      1. An attempt to limit one's self-addition to Slashdot (in the way that one would cut back on smoking, drinking, etc ...)
      2. An attempt to grab power from a source unlikely to relinquish it.
      3. A standard "go with the flow"/"flock of sheep" mentality of "all my friends are doing it, so I will, too," wither in support of the friends's cause or just because.
      4. Some other motive(s) I haven't seen or considered.

I'm betting for most that it's 2 or 3. For those with #3, especially if doing it to support a friend's cause, I understand that. #3 doing it "just cause your friends are" I understand that, as well (but I don't necessarily respect it as much). But, those that are doing it for #2, I think you have just embodied the proverb of "cutting off your nose to spite your face." You are trying to hurt yourself (by stopping something you enjoy) in hopes of hurting the very thing you belong to.

Personally, I think I'm with FK and just gonna remove myself from the moderation game. As I see it, this is Taco's site. He's word is law and he is god here. To some he may be a benevolent and wise god, to others he may be a incompetant and/or vengeful god. Either way, this place is his creation and he gets to do with it as he sees fit (well, with in the limits of his agreement with the sale of /. to OSDN). He decides who gets what and how. Honestly, do you really think that 20 or so people not writing a journal for a week is going to make a difference? In fact, I've seen several replies from many of you "black-outers" in AC format. This is recorded and counts towards your page views, so you are already defeating your own cause.

Another thought, why would you go about hurting what love in order to try and get more from it? Doesn't that seem counter-productive? I'm reminded of an old proverb "You catch more flies with honey than vinegar." You may be thinking "The squeaky (or in this case: quiet) wheel gets the grease," but my grandfather always told it another way, "The squeaky wheel gets replaced." I guess what I'm saying is why not try and work towards a better solution, rather than trying to eliminate some basic revenue for the site (by eliminating page views of ads). I wonder how many people doing this blackout are also subscribers, or have bought subscriptions for others as gifts? Just my own curiosity.

Maybe I just don't get it. I think the system works just fine. If you want more mod points, M2 more often, mod accordingly so that you don't get M2 overruled and be patient. Even if I thought the system didn't work, it's not my site or place to criticize it. I didn't create the place. The place does not need me. There are dozens of other similar sites (K5, Koc, Fark, etc...) that offer the same general amenities that anyone unhappy here can go to.

I look forward to next week when many of you start writing again cause it's been boring as hell around here without it.

-Ab (obviously not making any friends today)

ps. Helio, I have info on those Decals from my uncle, but I'll wait till next week to post about them in case you are still blacked out.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Blackout opinion

Comments Filter:
  • I'm kinda bored, and tempted to get the moderation issue back up again. Probably start a movement to get as many people as possible to turn off moderation completely. If I'm bored enough today, I'll do it.
  • less of a JE storm this morning - usually I build up quite the list of notifications over the weekend.
  • I don't agree with how mod points are handed out.

    Consider this; mod points are not given out to the most frequent viewers of the site. I understand doing that to prevent people from reloading the site constantly for the purpose of getting more mod points. Unfortunately, it also excludes Slashdot's most avid readers from obtaining mod points, too. This means that the system excludes the "best" users from fully participating in the community. Surely there has to be a better way to curtail obsessive reloading
    • Heh, my answer was going to be "I don't have a problem with how mod points are handed out cause it's not my site. If you have problems with it, tell Taco, not me," but I see you addressed that in your last paragraph. :)

      My main point is (and let me reiterate that I'm nopt telling anyone *NOT* to black out, I'm just trying to understand the thinking that leads to such a decision), "Why do people feel they have the right to demand change on something that is not their's to begin with?" I guess an even more
  • Mine is mostly (1), plus some degree of solidarity with heliocentric. This account was created so that I could do some additional metamoderation, and has heretofore only been used for that purpose. I'm fairly tempted to turn off moderation completely, as FK suggests.

    I'm with the other poster, in terms of disagreeing with the decision to exclude the most frequent page-loaders. I don't think that there would be a problem with excessive reloaders, due to the way that mod points are distributed. This ma
  • simply using another browser like IE will let me post AC in a story, and not erase the moderation done from multizilla
  • I view the blackout as more of an experiment than a protest. If users who have not had mod points for over a year cut back their usage of slashdot drastically for a week or so, it is expected that they would get mod points as a result. If they do not get mod points, then there is most likely some other reason for that - ie, blacklisting.

    Personally, I think there is a flaw in the reasoning. If a large number of people participate in the blackout, then it will not necessarily have the desired effect. The sup
  • ps. Helio, I have info on those Decals from my uncle, but I'll wait till next week to post about them in case you are still blacked out.

    Awesome. What do you need from me? What did he find out?
    • I'm still here... where are you, dude. Did you black out?
      • Sorry, been busy then forgot. Here is the email he sent me (names have been changed to protect the guilty).

        Abm0raz,

        Below is the information for the Overland Models catalog. I have been told that Overland makes their own decals fro the model they produce. Then the sell any extras they might have. This is why you guy can find Overland Decals easily. Have him try the web site below and see if that is any help.

        Ab's Uncle

        >
        >Ab's Uncle,
        >
        >Looks like Overland Models does (or, at least did) make dec
        • Thanks for the info, but it hasn't been of any help. Your contact is right that Overland made decals for their released models, and they sold the extras. However, that link to the current catalog doesn't list the Reading T-1 decal set. Overland is out of stock for the item. I and many others have contacted them.

          Let me be clear, I can't find the Overland decals at all. Easily or difficutly would be an improvement.

          Overland imported the Reading T-1 several years ago and has been out of stock for many ye
          • I'll forward the message onto my uncle and we'll see what he can drag up.

            Sorry it wasn't of any help.

            Any chance you might be able to get a picture or something (or even a half set) and have a really good photoshpper *coughcoughmontemplarcough* make the other side?

            -Ab
  • But I think you hit the nail on the head with the "joiner" mentality. And the geekly "Let's try this and see if it gets me mod points" is pretty legit, too.

    Haven't you noticed by now that folks are pretty willing to follow whatever trend seems to be en vogue at the moment? We might not glom onto what's in fashion with the mainstream, but within our own little circle, we're just like everyone else.

    ....Bethanie....

It's later than you think, the joint Russian-American space mission has already begun.

Working...