Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive


Forgot your password?
Check out the new SourceForge HTML5 internet speed test! No Flash necessary and runs on all devices. ×

Journal stoolpigeon's Journal: More on T-Mobile and My New Samsung Galaxy S III 3

I finally got the unlock code for my phone. This made me very happy. It should not have been as hard as it was but T-Mobile provided it after the second fax.

It's funny, every time I buy new stuff I always end up getting some unexpected education out of it. Here's what I learned today. The Galaxy S III does not present itself as a mass storage device via USB, it uses MTP. This has been mildly problematic. My Fedora machines were not prepared to deal with this. I've gotten things working but in a less than ideal manner. Something about the way KDE tries to automount it, or how it sees it as a camera OR - something with Samsung's MTP implementation is wacky.

What I have to do is plug in the phone in and then immediately mount it with mtpfs from the command line. If I wait too long it wont work. A little cheesy - but it will do until things catch up. There is a pymtp package in the repos - but I don't think it is supported any more. If it were I might play with it and see what I could do. Though I think things will get to a point where I just plug it in and it shows up properly in dolphin.

I do think it is odd that Google wrote an MTP browser for Apple machines but don't provide anything for linux. Samsung of course suggest using Kies - which is also only available on Win/Mac and a horrible little program anyway.

edit - fixed where I typed 'camera' instead of 'phone' on accident.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

More on T-Mobile and My New Samsung Galaxy S III

Comments Filter:
  • I have an Ubuntu 12.04 and a Debian wheezy setup - trying to get my external drive caddy to work.
    It did previously and had no idea what was going on. I saw something in the logs about mtp but had no idea what it was about.

    "What I have to do is plug the camera in and then immediately mount it with mtpfs from the command line. If I wait too long it wont work."
    This resembles my current problem.

    I now have a clue to work on.


    • That's funny - I plug in the phone - not camera. If I let the system just pick it up Dolphin shows it as a camera and says its a PTP device. I've also since discovered even that is not really working properly.

      Linux MTP support looks to be spotty at best - which is a bummer. It works flawlessly on my Windows machine, though I guess that makes sense - it being their protocol and all. I was digging around the Linux subreddit and it looks like a lot of people there just use a windows machine for their newer And

      • by tqft ( 619476 )

        Before this goes off and i can't comment anymore. Still haven't got it to work but just applied some updates & need to restart anyway so will check again.
        Thanks. Adding the MTP tools did get the hardware recognised, now trying to remember if I wiped the 2 x 500 GB and is possible the 1Tb disk is dead anyway. S it might all be working but no way to prove it.

"Be *excellent* to each other." -- Bill, or Ted, in Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure