Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive


Forgot your password?
Check out the new SourceForge HTML5 internet speed test! No Flash necessary and runs on all devices. ×

Journal Pirogoeth's Journal: [POLL] DRM-Free music 8

So, EMI becomes the first major label to make the DRM-free jump. Personally, while I see it as a good thing from different angles (customer: music can be played on any software/player, reseller: Apple makes more money because people will come to them to buy DRM-free tunes, supplier: EMI makes more money from the higher per-song price, artists: still get screwed) I don't see it as jumping for joy news. I'm not much of an audiophile, so the higher quality would probably be lost on me, and I drank the Apple kool-ade years ago, so I'll be using iTunes/iPods forever so the presence of the DRM doesn't really impact me..


1: If you buy music through iTMS, will you spend the extra $$$ for the higher-quality DRM-free versions?

2: Will you spend the $$$ to take up the offer to "upgrade" any existing music you have previously downloaded?

3: How long will it be until major label #2 makes a similar announcement?

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

[POLL] DRM-Free music

Comments Filter:
  • I hate the software and all its control over the iPod so I never did use it other than to sync with the nano. I never purchased any music and probably won't. The only new music I am interested in is Wierd Al's Straight Outta Lynwood but I would rather buy it from his site as a CD so I can rip it at my bitrate and so I have a physical disc to fall back on.

  • by ryanr ( 30917 ) *
    So, will Apple also be advertising that their iPods now hold half as much?

    I don't think I can hear any better than the 128AAC anyway, so I'm not that interested in the 256. I would like it if the DRM were just off, but no I don't think it's worth the extra money. I guess I'll continue to cut CDs and rip back to MP3 (I haven't had much time for the reverse engineering project to break the crypto directly.)

    I could maybe see buying one or two of the more expensive ones, if I were feeling too lazy to cut a CD a
    • It will depend on how easy it is to transcode straight to MP3.

      Should be as easy as it is now. Make sure you're set to rip to MP3 (Preferences>Advanced>Importing) at whatever bit rate you like, then Advanced menu in iTunes>Convert to MP3.
      • by ryanr ( 30917 ) *
        I don't think I've have AAC files that didn't have Fairplay on them before.
        • QTFairUse []... I *used* to have AAC files with FairPlay.

          Anything you rip from CD will be without FairPlay. Not that I do that, I rip to MP3. As for AAC files that have no FairPlay, you can convert to MP3 (transcode) with a right-click in iTunes.

          • As for the questions in the JE:

            1. Yes, I will.... Just to support it.

            2. If I find out which iTunes tracks that I bought were by EMI, I'll upgrade them all. Thing is: it's not easy to find out. I still have the backups of my FairPlay enabled tracks, yes....

            3. Good question.... I hope very fast.

            I don't steal music, but I want to be able to easily transport music from one computer to another without having to get the seal of approval from Apple.

          • by ryanr ( 30917 ) *
            I could get some unprotected AAC files. In fact, I believe I now have some, via Multiply. But if I'm going to the trouble of cutting a CD, the songs are going straight to MP3.
  • I've been buying from iTunes for a while, the benefit of 256kbps and DRM-free will be nice. I will probably upgrade my existing music, albeit slowly. I wonder if the upgrade price has album considerations...

"Be there. Aloha." -- Steve McGarret, _Hawaii Five-Oh_