Forgot your password?

typodupeerror

Comment: Re:Social Science is an oxymoron (Score 1) 107

by scruffy (#38929007) Attached to: Researchers Feel Pressure To Cite Superfluous Papers

I have bad news for you ... dig deep enough, and you find out all the other 'sciences' suffer from exactly the same problems.

In all sciences, reviewers will often ask authors to cite additional papers and provide some commentary on them. [How do your results differ?] Whether the papers are relevant is difficult to answer.

I have been on both sides of this. As a reviewer, I have often asked that additional papers be cited, sometimes my own. After all, I wouldn't be a reviewer if I didn't have some expertise. As an author, usually I agree the additional citations are relevant. Even I don't think so, I 'suck it up' in order to get my paper published. I'm sure the authors of the papers I reviewed sometimes felt the same way.

Welcome to peer-review.

Comment: Tell Them to Learn Math (Score 1) 315

by scruffy (#37805798) Attached to: Ask Slashdot: What To Tell High-Schoolers About Computer Science?
Rather than ruining their dreams, you make this an opportunity to make them realize how important math and science is in CS. If you know a little graphics, you could start by describing how a 3-D model is represented and how it is converted to a 2-D image. If you want a realistic simulation of the world, then you need to compute the physics correctly, meaning trig, algebra, calculus, forces, etc.

Comment: Old Idea (Score 1) 261

by scruffy (#37525558) Attached to: Should College Go Online?
The old-fashioned version of online courses, mail correspondence courses, have been around for a long time. Online courses have most of the same problems except for the potential of faster feedback.

Books have been around for even longer. Why take any courses when everything is already in books? I think there is some social reason why most students can't learn by themselves, but need to be physically in a class with other students in the same predicament. I guess it must be something about how all the students are in it together plus a little bit of competition. Of course, teacher-student interaction is a plus, but this aspect is overrated, I think. There are lots of classes where there is little interaction or only a few students are active.

Hempstone's Question: If you have to travel on the Titanic, why not go first class?

Working...