Comment Re:Small number (Score 1) 18
Why $750? Why not a RTL-SDR, with good timing, with a good dish and LNB, and just do everything else in software?
Because physics still matters. I think you missed a chapter in your RF engineering text. RTL-SDR gear is a fun toy, but it’s built around an 8-bit tuner with a 2.4 MHz bandwidth ceiling. The GEO Ku-band transponders in this study are running symbol rates up to 70 MS/s — two orders of magnitude higher. To capture that cleanly, you need a tuner and demodulator that can lock onto and maintain DVB-S2X carriers, apply proper forward-error correction, and handle multi-megabit baseband I/Q streams without dropping bits. That’s what the TBS-5927 and similar professional cards do, and that’s where most of that $750 went. The rest covers a 110 cm dish, a motorized mount for precise orbital alignment, and a low-noise block converter with the gain and linearity to hold lock across dozens of satellites.
Sure, you can “do it in software” — after the hardware front-end delivers a clean, stable stream. But a $30 RTL-SDR dongle isn’t going to demodulate a 70 megabaud DVB-S2X signal any more than a crystal radio can pick up Starlink. I love a good FFT as much as the next RF engineer, but you can’t do math on noise, which is exactly what your toy SDR would be doing.