Comment Re:Well well well (Score 1) 198
As others have pointed out, this is a bad analogy. Without passing judgment on whether or not RapidShare's conduct rose to this level, a better analogy (as much as I cringe at bringing murder into a conversation about copyright infringement) would be aiding and abetting in a murder. In copyright law, this is called secondary liability. Essentially, secondary liability requires some showing that on party has facilitated, induced, or is otherwise responsible for another parties' infringement of a copyright. The party does not have to directly infringe someone's copyright, similar to way a person aiding or abetting in a murder does not actually commit the murder.
Whether or not you agree with holding parties secondarily liable (and the DMCA has provided safe harbor mechanisms for many of the situations you probably wouldn't want service providers to be held liable), many cases have used the theory to hold parties liable that did not "originate the content" (remember Napster?).
Whether or not you agree with holding parties secondarily liable (and the DMCA has provided safe harbor mechanisms for many of the situations you probably wouldn't want service providers to be held liable), many cases have used the theory to hold parties liable that did not "originate the content" (remember Napster?).