Follow Slashdot stories on Twitter

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment: Much as it pains the Slashdot editors.... (Score 2) 299

by musth (#47665397) Attached to: Writer: Internet Comments Belong On Personal Blogs, Not News Sites

This seems to hold true for most broad-interest sites like newspapers and magazines where comments can be downright awful, as opposed to sites like Slashdot with a self-selected and somewhat homogeneous audience. It seems unlikely that using only blogs for responsive dialog with authors and peers could come close to matching the feedback and community feel of comments such as we see here. Is there a technical solution, or is this a biological problem imposed on the internet?

Ummmm, I would not classify Slashdot among the non-broken sites with broadly thoughtful, intelligent comments. And the hokey voting system here works just as much to hide thoughtful, but unpopular, opinion as it does to make trolls invisible. I believe Jackson is holding up sites where depth of though reigns and which don't depend on technological thumbscrews to maintain a veneer of quality.

It seems intuitively obvious to me, which means that it might be wrong. -- Chris Torek

Working...