Comment Re:Experience from an actual pilot (Score 1) 532
Keep in mind that there are a number of aircraft in service that were *designed* and probably manufactured before the boom of mp3 players and cell phones. Newer aircraft designs are likely better in terms of shielding. Should airlines adopt a policy that for older planes electronics are not permitted for takeoff/landing, but okay for newer planes? How many travelers pay enough attention to the flight attendant announcements at the start of flight to pick up on the policy for the particular plane?
Working with Automotive electronics, I have seen poor *new* designs in production that still show sensitivity to nearby transmitters. I assume aircraft electronics are at a higher standard. ...but also, could a $20 poorly designed mp3 player be particularly bad at EMI emissions?
This is very much a case of "better safe than sorry", because if you screw up on an airplane, the results could be very bad.
Besides, a forced 20 minute break from electronics is not a bad thing. And it's ONLY 20 minutes.