Comment Re:Audiophiles (Score 1) 468
You are correct on (2), but there is nothing to stop a sound system from emitting a controlled set of sounds, recording them with mikes, and calculating
Some modern audio systems have tried to implement such systems as you describe here, however, this only solves a very limited range of issues -- specifically, issues involving amplitude of a particular frequency. Yes, a sound system can emit a controlled sound and compensate for a particular frequency being louder than the others (this is basically an automatic EQ), however, a speaker cannot compensate for reverberation times or delayed reflections.
Remember that any room will have some amount of reverberation, and that reverberation is not always constant across the frequency spectrum. For example, you may hear a longer sustain for low frequencies than you do for high frequencies. Or perhaps, you have one particular frequency that tends to sustain a bit longer than the others. Reducing the amplitude of that particular frequency does not change the reverberation time. In fact, the amplitude of that frequency may be correct volume wise and reducing it would cause your sound to be even less balanced. There is no way to fix this without modifying the physical parameters of the room itself.
The other issue is called "early reflections". The idea here is that you have sound reflecting off of another surface which arrives at your ear later, most likely causing a stereo imbalance or phase issues at certain frequencies. For example, your right speaker projects sound toward you, but some of it reflects off of the left wall and then arrives at your left ear a split second later. Now your stereo field is incorrect and you have possible phase cancellations for certain frequencies. Again, the only way to correct for this issue is to stop the reflections by treating the room, an audio system cannot compensate for this.
Comment Re:Audiophiles (Score 3, Informative) 468
1. Is the quality of the source material good enough to make a difference? Crap quality audio will sound like crap on any speakers, no matter how expensive. However, if the source is of good quality (and some other conditions are true) then you can definately tell a difference.
2. Is the sound of the room masking the sound of the speaker? A speaker, no matter how good, can NOT compensate for a terrible sounding room. Standing waves, reflections, and damping from the room can ruin the sound of the audio. In order to properly hear the audio, this must be compensated for. Typically, you start by adding room treatment to deal with low-frequency standing waves and then work your way up to deal with high end comb filtering and reflection points in the room. The orientation of the room is important here as well, the optimal sound does depend very much on the placement of the speakers in the room relative to the listening position.
As for cables, the only real difference between cheap/expensive cables is how long they last. A cheap cable will most likely not put up with much abuse where as an expensive cable is more robust.