Comment Re:Pay up or shut it off. (Score 5, Interesting) 191
Yeah, it's like believing Disney when they changed the copyright law to make copyrights last (nearly) forever.
On some level, yes, if an author's book is worth $X, then in theory if you extend the copyright on it, it will now be worth $X + $Y. If you just stop thinking right there, you think "copyrights are good for authors" and side with Disney.
But when you look at the reality, the vast vast majority of authors will never see a single extra penny from the copyright extension. It's only the Disneys of the world that benefit, and they do so at a cost of stifling creativity for everyone else.
Same deal here: I guarantee you 99%+ of music artists are not making any more money as a result of these deals.