Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

Comment Re:The problem probably isn't the disks (Score 1) 89

Apparently the article referenced a video that referenced Win95, so USB is meh ish - yes if you have OSR2 and specialized drivers and the patience of a saint. But the hardware side isn't a problem, necessarily. Significant volumes of motherboards in the USB 1.x and 2.0 era had SuperIO chips that had floppy controllers in them (Intel moved it out of the southbridge before that I think). There are also plenty of slightly earlier motherboards with a floppy controller and PCI and PCI to USB is a solved problem off the shelf. Actually, ISA to USB is off the shelf too, but it's not a standard item, it's a retrocomputing thing (a very cool one but not produced in government volumes). And hybrid USB systems with PS/2 KB/mouse ports are of course common as dirt.

Comment Re:is this the next Y2K? (Score 1) 89

No, for whatever reason it never did; heck, even Teletext barely made it into public consciousness. Honestly it was niche in Australia too - it's really only in Europe that it seems to have been commercially important. After a little googling it seems the model we had was https://www.youtube.com/watch?... the KTX-9000UB - roughly an 8" screen. The keyboard was horrible, even worse than Minitel keyboards. The Tandy unit you reference was designed for an agricultural information network service, and actually predates the CoCo qua CoCo - the CoCo I is in fact a modification of that terminal and a direct genealogical descendant. They removed the modem, covered up some holes with labels, and generally hacked it into being a full computer.

Comment Re:is this the next Y2K? (Score 1) 89

Fun fact: at the time, most of the income came not from PCs but from refurbishing Sony Videotex terminals (David acquired pallets of them as essentially e-waste) and selling them to Amway reps, since that was how they placed their orders. It was basically a little Trinitron with a calculator style keyboard on a short cable. The profits on those were incredible.

Comment Re:Floppy disk/disc (Score 2) 89

Standard PC 3.5" disks are formatted to 720K (80t 2h 9spt) or 1.44MB (80t 2h 18spt). The drives usually support at least 82 tracks, and the media has "room" for typically at least 1 (DD) or 3 (HD) more sectors - hence 800K (80t 2h 10spt - identical at every level to the Atari ST disk format, except for a couple of bytes) and 1.6MB (80t 2h 20spt) were common overformatting options and more or less plug and play compatible with all PCs; the BIOS just saw the request and ran with it and the FDC said "sure why not?". Probably not readable on modern USB drives, I'd guess. Microsoft DMF (Distribution Media Format) on 3.5" HD disks was 1.68MB (80t 2h 21spt) and pretty widely compatible. IBM had a more or less identical format with a slightly different name, I forget what it was. Because I had a limited supply of disks I used one of those overformat utilities to get 82 tracks out of each disk which was all my drive would support - some drives would occasionally go higher. And now you know more about this than you ever cared.

Comment Re:is this the next Y2K? (Score 1) 89

I worked in the early 90s assembling PCs for a company called Swann Computers in Melbourne Australia, yes the same Swann that is now "Swann Security" and amazingly still exists. In the backrooms we had two of those Zeniths, I've no idea why - and four of the diskettes (count 'em, four). Those are the only ones I've handled personally. But I've had plenty of slightly assorted 2" disks come through my hands for use in dedicated word processors - there are several infuriatingly different and incompatible variants used for that application.

Comment Re:The problem probably isn't the disks (Score 1) 89

Heheh. Yeah. It won't surprise you to learn that I'm also very much into CRTs, and even now I get a bit of a shiver when I see people taking their CRT sets out into the back yard and (gently) power washing them. But it works! I mean, to be fair - I also get nervous whenever I wash my electric shaver, even though the last three or four I've owned have explicitly stated "this is how you clean me, run me under the sink". I just have this "electric ... not water ... mixn't" neural path so strongly connected that it probably won't get un-reinforced in the remainder of my lifespan.

Comment Re:ESP32 lightweight conversion (Score 1) 89

IT equipment in the FAA has always been a bit of a gray area to me. It's not avionics so it doesn't have the immense pressure of "well, we would rather use a transistor here but a vacuum tube is the approved component and it will take four years and $20,000,000 to qualify a transistor". But it does have supply chain attack considerations, if nothing else. It's not a question of signing off on "nothing bad could ever happen", more a matter of "it was signed off in accordance with procedure 113/207-1952, the conditions of which have been met" - and those conditions can be a long list of supplier paperwork stuff, nothing to do with technical vulnerability.

Comment Re:The problem probably isn't the disks (Score 5, Interesting) 89

I stand by my estimate - I have a reasonably large sample of drives of both known and unknown provenance and I've dealt with both mechanical and electrical issues on them. The amount of corrosion is surprisingly not terrible - for example I've got a half-dozen drives that were in a no-AC yard barn in Inglis, FL for ~20 years and they show no visible signs of corrosion (though the media stored with them are heavily molded and all the paper goods are similarly attacked). Cleaning and relubricating brought the drives to full function. I also have more than one compact Mac that's been stored in Midwestern winter conditions over ~10 years and while there was some galvanic corrosion between the steel chassis and the shielding plate (unknown composition) and some rust pitting on the connector areas, the drives were still fully functional. Anyway, a large amount of NOS is still in environmentally controlled warehouses and even if it isn't TODAY, the FAA can inspect before purchase.

Comment Re:ESP32 lightweight conversion (Score 2) 89

Emulate at what level - disk controller? Maybe a few really good students, most wouldn't know where to start.

Without bothering to try, I guarantee that AI has been trained on Gotek firmware and if you type in "I want to use an ESP32-C3 to emulate a floppy drive at the 34-pin interface level" you'd get usable vibe code pretty quick. And that is exactly where the bad students would start :P

Comment Re:The problem probably isn't the disks (Score 3, Interesting) 89

Floppy drives are very long-lived. Now, it is conceivable that the specific brand and model(s) that have NSNs are no longer super available on the secondary market, but I would feel confident in saying that for a very very modest amount of money - under $100 per workstation - the FAA could acquire enough stock today to ensure that every workstation has a working drive for the next fifty years. More, actually. Assumedly these drives are not used to boot and run the system's software and read/write files every hour - they are probably used once a day, or less frequently, to transfer some kind of updates. The key would be preventive maintenance; the failure mode for these drives is mostly related to lubricants drying out, though capacitor decay is an issue too (might be much less of an issue for a 2010-era drive; the ones I've had to repair for cap issues came from roughly the era of the Great Electrolyte Plague).

A more open question might well be - what computer are they using? A PC old enough to have a floppy controller won't run any modern software which means it won't be compliant with any modern security protocols. So the only real option is probably USB floppy drives.

Slashdot Top Deals

One can search the brain with a microscope and not find the mind, and can search the stars with a telescope and not find God. -- J. Gustav White

Working...