Posted: 4:30 PM, 5/8/09
By William Harwood
CBS News Space Consultant
Changes and additions:
04/15/09 (12:45 PM): Station crew says lab ready for six full-time crew members
05/07/09 (06:55 PM): Obama orders independent review of manned space operations; NASA 2010 budget unveiled
05/08/09 (04:30 PM): Reeling from projected budget cuts, NASA braces for manned space flight review
4:30 PM, 5/8/09, Update: NASA braces for manned space flight review
Reeling from projected budget cuts totaling more than $3 billion through 2013, NASA managers and engineers working to build a post-shuttle rocket system for an eventual return to the moon are bracing for a critical review ordered by the Obama administration that could set the agency on a different course.
The chairman of an independent review panel charged with evaluating NASA's post-shuttle manned space program said Friday he will bring an open mind and "go where the facts lead" in assessing the technical and economic feasibility of the space agency's current manned space program.
Norman Augustine, former chief executive officer of Lockheed Martin Corp., said the Review of United States Human Space Flight Plans Committee also will assess alternatives, including different rocket systems and alternative targets for exploration. The team's report is expected by August.
"We are planning to spend billions of dollars on the human space flight program and it's wise to be sure we're spending that the way we should," he told reporters in a teleconference. "New information becomes available all the time. And similarly, we have a new administration and it would probably be imprudent on their part not to examine this major of a program to be sure such a long term undertaking is still on a course that makes sense to them."
The cost of NASA's manned space program — and ongoing efforts by the Office of Management and Budget to cut spending — is at the heart of the review, announced Thursday when the Obama administration's fiscal 2010 budget request was unveiled.
"I think what it boils down to is we're being told there's no sense in being unrealistic and putting together a program that can't possibly be afforded, and we've been given some guidance," Augustine said. "I think one of the chronic problems NASA's encountered over the years has been that it usually had more programs than it had money. That can be dangerous when you're doing something as difficult as NASA does.
"So as we go through this evaluation, if we were to find there were reasons the budget didn't make sense in any way, I can assure you we would not be bashful about pointing that out, and I suspect the administration would want to know that anyway."
The Obama administration is asking Congress for $18.7 billion in funding for NASA in 2010, a watershed year for the civilian space agency as it tries to complete assembly of the International Space Station and retire the space shuttle fleet after just nine more flights.
NASA is designing a new rocket, called the Ares 1, and an Apollo-style Orion capsule to replace the shuttle, but the new system will not be ready for routine use until 2015. During the five years between the shuttle's retirement next year and the debut of Ares 1/Orion, NASA will be forced to buy seats on Russian Soyuz rockets to get U.S. astronauts to and from the space station.
NASA's long-range goal, set by the Bush administration, is to return to the moon by 2020, using Ares 1/Orion spacecraft to carry astronauts to orbit and then new heavy-lift Ares 5 rockets to boost the astronauts and lunar landers to the moon. The new rocket systems are the central elements of what NASA calls the Constellation program.
But funding has been a critical issue from the beginning. Congress and the Bush administration, which put NASA on its current course, did not provide the funding necessary to significantly reduce the gap between shuttle retirement and first flight of Ares 1/Orion.
The Obama administration's 2010 budget includes a near-term funding boost of $630 million for Constellation, thanks in part to about $1 billion routed to NASA as part of the economic Recovery Act.
But the administration's predicted budgets through 2013 show an overall cut of $3.1 billion for the exploration systems directorate in charge of Constellation, cuts that have sent shock waves through the NASA community.
"That's the real story," a senior space manager, who asked not to be named, said of NASA's Thursday budget briefing. "It's like that Sherlock Holmes thing, the real story is the dog that didn't bark in the night.
NASA officials said Thursday the budget numbers may change depending on the results of the Augustine review. But the agency turned down a request Friday for an interview with Jeff Hanley, Constellation program manager at the Johnson Space Center in Houston, to discuss the potential impacts of the projected cuts.
Against this backdrop, the Obama administration ordered the Augustine review of NASA's ongoing manned space exploration program, prompting speculation that budget pressures could lead to a major change of course. It's not yet known how any such a change might affect the gap between shuttle and any follow-on spacecraft, or whether the moon will even remain NASA's primary target.
"I must confess, as an individual I'm not thrilled with the fact that we have a gap," Augustine said. "But we have what we have.
John Holdren, director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, said the administration's objective "is to ensure that these programs remain on a strong and stable footing well into the 21st Century, and this review will be crucial to meeting that goal."
An OSTP statement said Augustine's panel will "assess a number of architecture options, taking into account such objectives as: 1) expediting a new U.S. capability to support use of the International Space Station; 2) supporting missions to the Moon and other destinations beyond low Earth orbit; 3) stimulating commercial space flight capabilities; and 4) fitting within the current budget profile for NASA exploration activities."
While the review is underway, NASA was told to continue work on Ares 1/Orion.
Augustine said he planned to assemble a team of experts with a broad range of space experience to evaluate the Constellation program and alternative architectures "both from an economic and a technical standpoint."
"We have a rather short time period to conduct our review, to be completed in August, and because of that we're drawing heavily on prior work and on our own experience as well as analyses
He said the panel's instructions are "to take a fresh, independent look at the human spaceflight program and go where the facts lead. And that's what we'll try to do. Obviously, the U.S. has excelled in the exploration and utilization of space for a long time. It's a source of great pride to our nation as well as, I might say, to myself.
"I also have long believed it should be a balanced program that includes both robotics and human involvement. Our focus will be on the human spaceflight aspect. The president has made rather clear he's very supportive of human spaceflight, he believes it's important from an economic and technical and scientific leadership standpoint. I certainly share that view and I believe this is an important task and I look forward to leading it."
Quick-Launch Web Links:
CBS News Space Shuttle Status Reports:
CBS News Space Shuttle Quick-Look Page:
CBS News Breaking Space News Page:
NASA Shuttle Web: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601714-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
NASA Station Web: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601715-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
Spaceflight Now: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601716-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
Hubble Space Telescope Background:
HST Overview: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601718-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
Servicing Missions: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601719-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
Space Telescope Science Institute: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601721-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
Hubble Site: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601722-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
NASA HQ Hubble Page: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601723-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
Goddard Hubble Page: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601724-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5
Ball Aerospace Hubble Page: http://ct.cbsnews.com/clicks?t=202601725-f10ca05ebe88ea6189f7f7250b07b818-bf&brand=CBSNEWS&s=5