Please create an account to participate in the Slashdot moderation system


Forgot your password?

Comment: Interesting - but are they better than dice? (Score 1) 189

by bcarl314 (#17948744) Attached to: Statistical Accuracy of Internet Weather Forecasts
I've always wondered, but never had the time nor determiniation to find out, whether weather forecasts are more or less accurate than coin tosses and dice. I've always wanted to run an experiment similar to this :

Take the 5 day temp forecast from a national weather site (NWS/, etc) and write the high / lows on one row.

Then, flip a coin and roll a single die.
Start with yesterday's high and low.

If you toss "heads" then add the number rolled on the die to the high temp for that day. If you toss "tails" then subtract. Do this for high and low temps for each of the five days.

Repeat this routine for a while, logging actual temps, then, after a certain amount of time. Compare your "forecasts" to the NWS / forecasts.

I've always wondered which would be more accurate.

Maybe this guy would run that test! ;)

"Being against torture ought to be sort of a bipartisan thing." -- Karl Lehenbauer