
Journal GMontag's Journal: Some Criticism of Hitchens 5
12-23-03: Historians/History
Mr. Hitchens's Revisionism of His Own History
By Sean Wilentz
Mr. Wilentz is a professor of history at Princeton University.
It is a short article that is long on theory and short on substance. The author takes a couple of paragraphs of a 13 Sep. 2001 Hitchens piece So is this war? in the Guardian where Hitchens does a lot of pondering, some may say "empty pondering", immediately after 9/11.
I hate that kind of stuff... (Score:2)
Re:I hate that kind of stuff... (Score:1)
Re:I hate that kind of stuff... (Score:2)
Re:I hate that kind of stuff... (Score:1)
With the coming of the latest Iraq action
Re:I hate that kind of stuff... (Score:2)
I have only read these two articles involving him (no excuse, really...should have dug more before spouting off), and the reason I chose the two quotes I did was to point out what I thought the headline of the article was probably using for fodder.
The bulk of the content in there echoes (some of) my own feelings about the whole m