Forgot your password?
User Journal

Chacham's Journal: What's the point of comment titles? 3

Journal by Chacham

Writing a subject for a Journal is essential. It is a quick display about what the JE is about. Although most people use it for shock value, I appreciate it because I read very few JEs now. I just skip everything that doesn't have a descriptive title. Email is pretty much the same. I skip just about everything, unless I recognize the title.

Comments are different. Who actually looks at the title? The only time I see it as being usefull is when looking at an old list of comments. But, even then, seeing the story/journal its connected to tells me more about it then the title does.

As such, I've decided to skip titles. Since I can't, they're all the same by me now. Much like the "from the ... dept." I doubt if anyone has even noticed.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

What's the point of comment titles?

Comments Filter:
  • Comment titles can sometimes be useful, I find (although nobody ever reads what I say because A) I'm boring and B) I always comment on the day after) - but most often they are not (like now). IMO they should be optional...

    Saying that, it does add a bit of breaking up of the comments.
  • by turg (19864) *
    (Hmm. I think a theme is developing in my responses to your JE's :-)

    Must every feature be useful to every user? How many users must use a feature for it to be worth implementing?

    If it is already implemented and it takes next-to-no-resources to maintain it, what is the point at which it should be removed because less than a certain number of people use it?
    • I never said that it should be removed. Just wondering why it's there. Is it useful to some? Who? And why?

Every successful person has had failures but repeated failure is no guarantee of eventual success.