Have all UI devs completely lost it?
Windows 8: Metro and no Start Menu. No one I've thrown the developer's release to can figure out how to make it work.
GNOME 3: Just plain crazy. Users I throw at it have no idea what to do.
Unity: Utter and complete suckage. I've been using *NIX for decades and can't use Unity (or GNOME 3). Users I throw at it just stare blankly.
OS X: I know Mac-heads love it. I've tried it, via theming Ubuntu. Better than Win8, G3, or Unity, but not as good as the plain 'ol Start Menu.
I'm sorry, but menus make sense on a desktop, they're reasonably untuitive, and there is absolutely no reason whatsoever to change it.
And in changing it, Ubuntu (and G3) are shooting themselves in the foot. Look, Win8 is going to ship with a user interface with which users cannot interface. G3 and Unity are no better, and I see no reason to believe that Ubuntu has seen the light with HUD.
If Ubuntu had a user interface that was actually intuitive, the distro would have the opportunity to get users who will throw their hands up at Win8 in disgust. Unfortunately, Ubuntu has an interface that leaves users with a "deer in the headlights" look.
This is a stupid interface. All modern interfaces are about to suck (stupidly). Pity Linux couldn't be different at a time when it would work to its advantage.
Dakota Smith