Just for the sake of argument (though I agree with many of your points), I'll offer up some counter-points:
- Services - A book can't deliver the newspaper to you, without any need for intervention, or killing trees.
- Search - e-books make it really easy to find that quote you're looking for.
- Dictionary - A good e-reader lets you instantly lookup a word that you don't fully understand, in my opinion enhancing overall enjoyment of the book.
- Book price - If/when bookstores start doing things as they should be done, e-books will be much cheaper than a new, retail copy of a book.
- As XKCD happily pointed out, a 3G-enabled e-reader is essentially
The Guide
- Obsolescence - Most books sold for this will be in
.epub,
.txt, or
.pdf. I'm absolutely confident that in 5 years, all of these formats will still be easily readable, and if not, there will be many free conversion tools to make them so. In fact, the more of these e-readers that get sold, and the more e-books that people buy for them, the more important this will become, and the more of a "sure thing" this will be.
Also, I'm trying to talk myself into buying one of these things. It's just
so damn cool. Now, by no means will I stop buying new books, or get rid of my old ones, but I also won't feel any guilt pirating/fair use-ing e-books of books that I own or buy. Plus, there's lots of good, freely available e-books out there, even if you don't count Project Gutenberg.