Comment Re:My opinion on the matter. (Score 1) 826
- Useless on a server - where you only reboot 4 times a year or so and never have to hot-plug anything or change wireless networks.
Bull. Lots of servers currently run daemontools or similar, or else they use some other hack, because the SysVinit doesn't have any way to restart services (like crond) the one time they exit after running fine for months...
That is a feature, not a problem.
There are multiple programs out there to restart demon processes, if needed, with varying amounts of notifications to the admin, and varying interfaces. You pick which works best for you. An embedded appliance may need a 'restart at all costs, write a log and forget about it' program. You may want your restart program to email you, while someone else may prefer a web interface to check status. Maybe some programs should only be restarted in specific circumstances.
The Unix way is not to try to be everything to everybody, but to pick a specific function and do it really well, in a way that lets others do the same thing in a different way if they find the need to do so.
(I'll admit the biggest red flag to me about Systemd is binary logs - that prevents many useful things, in my experience.)