Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:"we provide network access as part of rent" (Score 2) 185

The problem is, most US Universities have long histories of cynically abusing their students as captive markets for textbooks and other products and services. Most people in university administration have no problem with, for example, mandating which texbooks students must use based on which will earn the University bookstore, the publisher, etc. more money rather than which textbooks are actually better for learning.

Comment Re:Captive? (Score 5, Interesting) 185

Anybody who doesn't like what they are doing can rent somewhere else. If their college has an exclusive contract with them (unlikely but possible), people can choose a different college.

I was going to methodically criticize this sentence but then I realized I shouldn't need to. Anyone with half a brain should be able to see what's wrong with the idea that the easy remedy to this sort of thing for consumers is to "choose a different college"!

Comment Re:As painful as it is... (Score 1) 552

"Ask Slashdot" is supposed to be asking the Slashdot community a specific question since we're supposed to be a reasonably knowledgeable community. Somehow it always seems to devolve into these tangents instead of being useful. It's especially bad when the person asking the question is facing personal tragedy and all they get are insensitive, unhelpful and morbid suggestions.

Comment Re:Community support is usually better support (Score 1) 253

That filter can be a forum, a web form that forces you to view every single article in the knowledge base, or a team of barely trained monkeys who are underpaid, and will burn out within 3-6 months from being asked the same questions over again by customers who are, on average, so dense that they don't mention the device in question isn't even turned on until they have already nodded along and gone through 30 minutes of "troubleshooting".

Or a decent FAQ or knowledge base.

Comment Re:As painful as it is... (Score 1) 552

That makes it rather a lot more hypothetical.

And even less helpful. This is an "ask Slashdot" article. A question has been asked by someone in real need. I wish I had a real answer, but I really am not up on the state of the art in the field. I do know a counter-productive non-answer when I see one and, in the described situation, posts like yours are exactly such.

Comment Re: As painful as it is... (Score 1) 552

I didn't mean a ritual sacrifice. I was simply pointing out how ridiculously morbid the discussion on this is. Someone posts looking for advice for a loved one in distress and, instead of a helpful discussion of the state of the art in brain/machine interface and assistive technology, scores of posters descend with ghoulish suggestions regarding her and a perfectly healthy baby who is not the source of the problem (I suppose we can chalk that one up to complete reading mis-comprehension).

Religion or philosophy may help her in the long run (or not, every person is different), but they hardly need to turn to Slashdot for that. If the family is at all religious, I'm sure they've already received spiritual advice from whatever pastor/priest/cleric/guru they already have.

Comment Re: As painful as it is... (Score 1) 552

Why didn't they dump the kid and save her for God's sake???

They can make another kid, there is only one of her!!

The child has already been delivered by c-section. It's right there in the summary! Or do you believe that there's some way to retroactively sacrifice the baby to fix the unrelated brain tumour?

Comment Re:Why not leave? (Score 2) 304

You could argue that. If there is a judge involved, he wouldn't be blinded by the splendour of your argument.

Of course, the same judge will wisely and sagely nod along in complete agreement when the government is arguing that ubiquitous surveillance and tracking in public is ok because a surveillance camera connected to a massive computational back end is just like a patrol cop.

Comment Re:Not First Amendment (Score 1) 160

lol.. It's not quite that simple. The 13th amendment makes slavery and/or involuntary servitude illegal in the US and jurisdictions the US controls and grants congress the power to enforce it.

Actually, it's not that simple either. The 13th amendment makes certain types of slavery and/or involuntary servitude illegal in the US and jurisdictions the US controls. Basically, hereditary slavery is out. So, if you're currently a slave, your children aren't automatically slaves. The 13th amendment still allows for you to become a slave either temporarily or permanently as a result of any conviction for any crime. That includes being sold to private citizens effectively as property. The only real protection is the 8th amendment, which vaguely protects you from cruel and unusual punishment. Of course, the 8th didn't protect people who were slaves back before the 13th. There's the argument that what was being done to them from birth wasn't a punishment, therefore it didn't fall under the 8th. This same argument crops up a lot in modern times, often in relation to various lists (no fly, terrorist watch, sex offender, plus various others, some of which are probably still secret) which, although quite harmful to be on, are supposedly not punishments. Of course, that argument is in complete defiance of the 5th amendment where life, liberty and property are not supposed to be deprived without due process of law. So, anyway, hereditary slavery was basically unconstitutional _before_ the 13th amendment, but that fact was simply ignored, and the 13th amendment only did away with hereditary slavery.

Slashdot Top Deals

"Gravitation cannot be held responsible for people falling in love." -- Albert Einstein

Working...