I work at the University of Massachusetts.
I had a conference call with Warner today about this very subject.
This is a good thing. This is just what the EFF wanted:
http://www.eff.org/wp/better-way-forward-voluntary-collective-licensing-music-file-sharing
Now we have a chance to make this a reality, and you guys are shooting it down?
This "music tax" is a fair way for artists and distributors to get paid while letting people listen and share music however they want. No DRM. You get to keep the music after you leave the university. Use any file sharing network you want.
It would only cost $2 to $10 a month (still in the works, they want our input)... what more do you guys want? This is a huge improvement over the current choice of DRM vs. a lawsuit.
Warner wants to work with the Universities to help implement this... I spoke with them directly this morning, and I really believe Warner is trying to do good with this system. Please, let us give them a chance to do something right. This isn't just Warner pressing some evil tax on the Universities, it is just a pilot to let file sharing thrive without limitations.
I hope this program succeeds, I truly do.