Follow Slashdot blog updates by subscribing to our blog RSS feed

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Top 3 (Score 1) 339

I agree, but I don't think that the singularity breaks into the Top 3 sci-fi faith-based initiatives. I usually count them like:

(1) Technology will reduce our work hours until almost all of us are leisurely, creative, artist-types.
(2) Automated warfare will result in conflicts occurring in which almost no humans die.
(3) There is intelligent life in outer space that we can possibly contact.

Comment Re:Wait a sec (Score 2) 772

Disagree. What is "hypothesis testing" (a well-established element of inferential statistics) if a hypothesis is "without a way to make or test predictions" (according to you)? And other problems.

"For a hypothesis to be a scientific hypothesis, the scientific method requires that one can test it." [Wikipedia: Hypothesis]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypothesis_test

Comment Re:public employee unions poison (Score 1) 688

So you're talking about a theoretical free-market company that doesn't exist. The rest of us are talking about actual companies as they really exist, which are generally irrational, poorly run, anti-democratic, and at the whim of some possibly charismatic but out-of-touch business owner. Small or large. Whether with natural, artificial, or no monopoly.

Comment Re:public employee unions poison (Score 1) 688

"There are no 'corporate-style administrators' in public schools..."

Pretty much all of your statements are factually false, so I'll just deal with the very first one as an exercise. Consider where I teach: the City University of New York, the largest public urban university in the country. Ultimately CUNY is run by its Board of Trustees (mostly appointed by the mayor and governor). In the last 25 years, how many corporate executives have been on the board? 24 (53% of the total). How many corporate lawyers have been on the board? 12 (27% of the total). How many many labor leaders have been on the board? 0 (zero). How many of the current trustees have a PhD? 0 (zero). How many make their living teaching at a university? 2 (out of 15).

http://www.psc-cuny.org/clarion/may-2014/cuny-trustees%E2%80%99-index

Comment Re:public employee unions poison (Score 1) 688

I read this as whining that an administrator just doesn't want to do any friggin' work as part of their job (namely: document and prove that a teacher is negligent). Here is a study on when unions are more involved in hiring/firing of teachers, and the result is that they are far more aggressive about firing teachers than administrators.

"Nonetheless, CTs [consulting teachers] rose to the challenge - not in all cases, but at a much higher rate than principals - and when necessary, they recommended nonrenewal... The result was that out of 88 new teachers who were in the program in its first year, 11 (12.5 percent) were not renewed for employment... In the year immediately before PAR [peer assistance and review], only three teachers out of a teaching force of almost 3,000 were not renewed."

I've also seen this kind of thing first-hand. At my current job observations are done by fellow teachers (sit in my class for an hour, fill out a detailed 7-page report, have a sit-down conversation with me after I read it, every semester). At my prior job observations were to be done by the assistant dean (bagged it off for 3 years, I begged and pleaded to get something on file, he sat in on an introductory computer class for 5 minutes, wrote down a notecard-sized piece of garbled nonsense totally unrelated to the class content). In summary: Administrators are pretty lazy about doing their job.

Slashdot Top Deals

"Engineering without management is art." -- Jeff Johnson

Working...