They don't want people looking at their devices with their headphones in when the captain says "brace for impact" a moment before you're supposed to land normally. It's not that hard to just be ready for an important announcement before takeoff and landing. And they're right that you want everything stowed away for those two phases of the flight.
I'll take my chances that even if I did brace for impact it wouldn't make a significant difference in my survival or chance of injury.
No you wont. You'll sue the airline for not making the announcement clear enough. Airline will lose and they'll ban PED completely. Personally, I dont want this scenario.
Are people that afraid to be left alone with their thoughts for five minutes that they cant put their tablets down. The article said,
the union would also be fine with a policy that allows devices to be turned on during takeoff and landing, as long as they're stowed away.
Why is it that hard for people to put down their tablets for 5 minutes during the most dangerous time of the flight? Are people really that self-entitled these days (and I used to argue against this so I really dont want it to be true).
I'd also like to point out, from the article:
But the attendants union is concerned about the safety implications of the move. They claim that in at least one instance, a tablet "became a projectile during turbulence,"
First let me say, I fucking told you so. For years I've been saying the real threat is from tablets and phones becoming projectiles. For years people have been calling this nonsense and I'm going to trust a cabin crew union over a butterfingered tablet owner any day.
Now this is only a significant risk during specific situations such as take off, landing and heavy turbulence. Is it really too much to ask that people demonstrate a little common sense and self restraint... and put the devices away during these specific times. I use my tablet all the time on budget airlines... but I know enough about flying to stow it when things get a little too rough. This is made even worse by the fact people aren't even holding onto their tablets, I mean, who holds a 10" tablet for 6 hours... Fuck no, you lean it against the seat in front or on the tray table, sit back and enjoy your video. As it's only being held there by it's own weight the risk of it becoming a projectile during turbulence is very real.
Finally yes, I've been asked to stow my dead tree based book for take off on several airlines ranging from Southwest to Singapore to Cebu Pacific.