Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×

Comment Re:Fewer candidates to draw from... (Score 2, Insightful) 580

Nope, the person offering it for download is making the copy and distributing it.

A copy is defined in the Copyright Act (17 USC 101) as a material object in which a copy is fixed. A hard drive is a material object, a flash drive is a material object, RAM is a material object. But data coming in over the network is not a material object. The downloader causes that data to be written to some sort of storage medium on his end, thereby making a new copy. The person on the other end of the connection is in trouble too, but it is clear in the statute, and settled in the caselaw, that downloading can be infringing.

No more so than if you were to use a tape record to copy music from the radio or a VCR to copy a movie or TV show.

That's like saying that murdering someone with a gun is no more murder than murdering them with a knife or with poison. All of the things you mention are also infringing, if of copyrighted works and without permission. There may be applicable exceptions, but there just as easily might not be.

decisions like the Sony Beta Max case would probably bar cases against most copying that didn't involve distribution or public performances

It didn't. In fact, if you read the Sony case, you'll see that the Court expected that not all home taping of TV would even be a fair use. All that mattered was that there was enough possibility of VCR recording being legal sometimes that copyright didn't require that the technology be banned altogether.

For instance, you walking down the street singing Lady Gaga tunes or listening to a radio playing it in which others could hear would not be a violation unless someone paid you to do it or you were advertising something and using that to attract attention or similar.

It's a public performance, and would be prima facie infringing.

Comment Re:Fewer candidates to draw from... (Score 5, Informative) 580

Further, the laws against "piracy", (which is NOT the same as downloading)

There are no laws against "piracy" per se; rather there are laws against copyright infringement, which downloading commonly is.

were intended primarily to punish people who make bulk copies of copyrighted works and sell them for a profit.

The statute doesn't require infringement en masse, nor does it require selling them for a profit. Perhaps you'd like to read it? It's 17 USC 501. It refers to other sections, in particular 17 USC 106, and 101.

That's essentially what "copyright piracy" means. It's a legal term.

No it's not. The correct legal term would be copyright infringement.

And downloading doesn't qualify. Downloading isn't a "crime" at all. It's just a copyright violation.

No, any copyright infringement which meets the prerequisites of 17 USC 506 is a crime. For example, if you willfully download a work in an infringing manner, and that work has a retail value of over $1,000 (easily doable with certain computer programs), that's a criminal infringement.

And it sure as hell isn't "stealing"

This is the first, and perhaps only thing in your post that's correct.

Comment Re:Fewer candidates to draw from... (Score 1) 580

The only problem is that there is no federal law against downloading. There is about copying and distributing which whoever offers it for download would definitely be doing but no law against you downloading it. All the court cases you see about it stem from the illegal distribution.

When you download, you necessarily make a new copy. If the work is copyrighted, and you lack permission or an applicable exception to copyright, you're infringing.

Comment Re:Alternative headline (Score 3, Insightful) 429

This, a thousand times owner. I rely on 'net connectivity for a living. If my internet drops, I'm packing my bags and going to one of my backup locations. One of those is a McDonalds, another is a local gas station that has wifi (?) and a friends house. The friends house is my first pick of course and usually the one I get. But if I have to go to McDonalds or the gas station and somebody is making it impossible for me to make a living and feed my family because someone is torrenting, I will feel every bit justified in using bithammer. Why?

Because I have every right to use the network as the guy making it impossible for me to use it.

Submission + - Four Job Stages to recognize for Success (tidbitsfortechs.com)

toygeek writes: In the past several years This Tech Geek has found himself all over the place with jobs. I had a few different full time jobs in that time, and I also run my own business on the side. With this unusually rapid cycle, I was able to spot some trends in myself that led me to good success in my current position. Perhaps you’ll recognize the same Job Stages in your experiences. So I give you Ryan’s Four Job Stages for Success. [Note: Original Content, not Blog Spam]

Submission + - Four Job Stages to recognize for Success (tidbitsfortechs.com)

toygeek writes: In the past several years This Tech Geek has found himself all over the place with jobs. I had a few different full time jobs in that time, and I also run my own business on the side. With this unusually rapid cycle, I was able to spot some trends in myself that led me to good success in my current position. Perhaps you'll recognize the same Job Stages in your experiences. So I give you Ryan's Four Job Stages for Success.[Editors note: This is original content written by the submitter; it is not blog spam]

Submission + - Four Job Stages to recognize for Success (tidbitsfortechs.com) 2

toygeek writes: In the past several This Tech Geek has found himself all over the place with jobs. I had a few different full time jobs in that time, and I also run my own business on the side. With this unusually rapid cycle, I was able to spot some trends in myself that led me to good success in my current position. Perhaps you'll recognize the same Job Stages in your experiences. So I give you Ryan's For Job Stages for Success. (Editors note: this is original content by an actual geek- not blog spam)

Comment Re:Start menu usage dropped in lieu of what? (Score 2) 269

Why not give users the option to use both?

The dumb thing is pinning a run command to the task bar: this requires both mouse input and keyboard input to do anything. It's far more sensible to use a keyboard shortcut for "run"; I can type alt-f2 (linux) or meta-R (windows) and then a program name and get it without reaching for the mouse.

Comment Re:The whole article is just trolling (Score 1) 795

You are suggesting that every single one of a multitude of completely independent temperature records are all wrong. You are trying to dismiss them on the irrational basis that they all point in the same direction by slightly different amounts.

Furthermore you are assuming that every single one of a multitude of completely independent temperature records are all wrong in the same direction, imposing your pre-determined bias upon them.

You are baselessly filtering out any satellite data that doesn't fit the story you want to hear.

You are baselessly filtering out ocean temperatures, which account for 90% of climate heating, because it doesn't fit the story you want to hear.

You are engaging in wild conspiracy-theoryism claiming (or implying) that some hundredthousand scientists are ALL too stupid to account for novice-level obvious measurement difficulties, or that they are ALL conspiring to deliberately lie.

And most of all you're denying THE LAWS OF PHYSICS.
CO2 lets sunlight in and blocks the escape of thermal radiation. There is no possible dispute there. End of argument. The science is utterly and unarguably settled. All that's left at that point is determining the size of the effect.

It's astounding that it somehow doesn't make it into your conscious awareness that you are baselessly ignoring anything and everything that doesn't fit the story you want to hear.

-

Slashdot Top Deals

"God is a comedian playing to an audience too afraid to laugh." - Voltaire

Working...