Comment Re:The island was not purgatory! (Score 1) 4
One unanswered question for me is "who was the Smoke Monster"? Jacob's brother doesn't fit- for the SM was obviously on the island in Egyptian times (from the hieroglyphs on the wall of the temple) but Jacob's biological mother arrived in Roman times (from the use of Latin as a common language).
Well, I think it's certainly plausible that, although Jacob's brother was the smoke monster we saw active on the island, he wasn't the *only* smoke monster that has ever existed on the island. There were people on the island before Jacob/MiB ever got there. Doesn't seem too much of a stretch to imagine that the MiB wasn't the first guy to get tossed down the golden-hole (indeed, the skeletons we see down there attest to that).